The Akeidah

I.  Extent of the Trial

The Akeidah was the final and the supreme trial of Abraham. As we have seen, it was necessary to submit Abraham to ten trials in order to elevate him to his spiritual peak. After the Akeidah, he had thirty-eight years to live. But he was not tested again because he had already gained his ultimate height, nothing could be gained by testing him further. The Akeidah has assumed a central role in Jewish liturgy.

Like every trial, the Akeidah forced its subject to make a painful choice that ran counter to his nature and inclination. The test can be understood on many levels and in many dimensions ~ all of them valid. That it was the climatic test of Abraham’s greatness is reason enough for it to have been of such complexity, for it stands to reason that the extent of the reward called for an ordeal of parallel proportions.

Abraham had waited a hundred years for the gift of a son. He had been told by God that his heir must be born from Sarah, but it was a physical impossibility for them to have a child together. God raised him above the stars which are His emissaries to preside over the natural functioning of the universe and told him that the rules of nature do not apply to him and Sarah. As Abram and Sarai, they would not have children, but as Abraham and Sarah, they would (15:5). The couple waited many years after that vision until Isaac was finally born to him. Now they were both old, Abraham was 137 and Sarah was 127. Their rejuvenation had not continued; they had had no other children together. Isaac was thirty-seven, a mature man who had proven himself to be a deserving successor to Abraham’s mantle. Now Abraham was asked to slaughter him. Now in human terms, the task of him was incomprehensible. An only son! There was no chance short of a miracle that another son would be born ~ could another miracle be expected? To bring him to the altar and to inflict the cut with his own hands!

Abraham had built an empire of accomplishments in the service of God. In the sense that the offspring of the righteous are their good deeds, Abraham had armies and armies of children. From the time he was fifty-two he had been teaching the multitudes and leading people under the wings of the Shechinah. Though he lived in an immoral, idolatrous society, even they considered him a ‘Prince of God’ (23:6) and he gained respect wherever he went. Everywhere his teaching was that people must emulate God who abhors cruelty and loves kindness, that human sacrifice is murder, and that idolatry is a denial of the true God.

What would happen to his followers and those who admired him if he slaughtered Isaac and the world learned that Abraham’s teachings had been violated in the grossest manner by the preacher himself? His entire lifetime of achievement would have been nullified. He would have been despised, vilified, and ridiculed. Human nature being what it is, not only his critics, but even his past followers, would probably have embarked on orgies of excess, because the one supreme moral force acting as the conscience of the world would have been irreparably discredited. Human beings can endure many forms of suffering, but none is more difficult than disgrace ~ the fate awaiting Abraham when he returned from Mount Moriah without Isaac at his side. Could he endure all that in order to satisfy the wish of God.

Abraham had been as loyal a servant of God as had ever lived. He had been assured by God that his destiny would be continued through Isaac and none other. Now there would be no Isaac and as a result the work of Abraham himself would not endure. On the other hand, he understood that the greater goal of sanctifying God’s Name would be enhanced by his deed. For the sacrifice asked of him would demonstrate conclusively that Abraham held back nothing from God ~ not his son, not his reputation, not even his lifetime of spiritual fulfillment. In God’s scale of values, that degree of dedication outweighed all the jeers of scoffers and skeptics. It mattered not that Abraham would lose his following or that not a soul would understand the magnitude of his deed. He was alone when he began his work but that did not detract from his greatness; he would be alone when he finished his work and be even greater because he would give up so much. God does not measure value in numbers. What is more his supreme obedience would prove that accomplishment on earth, accomplishment measurable in human terms, had no ultimate value at all if God’s will were otherwise. Because it was the Divine Will, the destruction of his life’s edifice would be his greatest and most genuinely tangible achievement because, and in the Heavenly balance, it would outweigh everything else he had ever done.

Intellectually, Abraham could surely have understood that infinitely better than we could. Could he also feel it is the depths of his soul and with all of his emotions? It was his son, his loss, his sacrifice. Could he feel the same joy in serving God by slaughtering Isaac that he had in raising him?

The character traits of Israel became engraved into the national spiritual ‘genes’ through the acts and particularly the trials of the Patriarchs. We are Abraham’s offspring and the heirs of his submission to God’s will. We are descendants of Abraham, but he was a son of Terach. Therefore, it is impossible for us to fully comprehend the awesome nature of his response to God’s call to slaughter Isaac. To say that we benefit from his legacy is not to imply that we would do equally well ~ far from it. But we cannot divorce ourselves from our heritage; therefore we cannot imagine how sever the trial was for Abraham who had no patriarchal ancestor named Abraham. Suffice to say that Abraham proved himself so well that he attained perfection in the eyes of the Supreme Judge. That there are those who question his uniqueness on the ground that countless Jewish parents throughout the ages have made similar sacrifices is testimony to how well he succeeded. So totally did Abraham channel his personal ambitions and needs to the will of his Master, that the heritage remains strong almost thirty-seven centuries later.

II.  Uniquely Abraham’s

What of Isaac? The Akeidah is counted as one of Abraham’s trials, but surely Isaac was being tested as well. As we see, Isaac’s achievement was awesome and his performance during those fateful three days leading up to his ascent to the altar has remained part of the national heritage as has Abraham’s. They were partners in approaching the Akeidah and they are partners in affecting us today by their accomplishment. Why then is the trial aspect of the Akediah not ascribed equally to Isaac ~ or, since he was the one who volunteered his own life, why is it understood primarily as Abraham’s trial and only secondarily as Isaac’s?

In commenting on this question, Rabbi Yosaif Yoizel Horowitz of Novardok remarked: “It is harder to live like a Jew than to die like a Jew!”

Isaac was ready to offer his life. That done, all would have been over. He was fully prepared to give everything for the sake of God, but he would not have had to deal with the aftermath.

The supreme sacrifice is not to be regarded lightly but such acts of heroism are not uncommon in human experience. People risk their lives for far smaller causes and they are soon forgotten. Great moments evoke great responses even from ordinary people; surely one would not expect less from Isaac. But Abraham would have to go on, facing Sarah, facing the world, rebuilding his shattered life, once more opening his tent to travelers who would now be afraid to accept the hospitality of the ‘barbarous old man’ who had killed his own son, preaching the word of God to people who would call him a hypocrite, wondering if the lack of a future Jewish generation might not be his unforgivable sin for having allowed his fully grown son to remain unmarried for so long. Isaac had to die like a Jew, but Abraham had to bear the infinitely harder burden of carrying on, of continuing to live like a Jew.

Abraham and Isaac had different primary traits in the service of God. Abraham was the person of ‘chesed’ (kindness) whose primary drive was to help others and use his generous nature to draw them close to God. For him, the Akeidah was a trial of awesome proportions both for what he was called upon to do to Isaac and the effect it would have on his relationship to society. But Isaac was the person of ‘gevurah’ (strength). He was inner-directed and self-critical. He sought to perfect himself and remove any hint of imperfection in himself. To Isaac, the call to give up his life was not difficult. If the way to purge his imperfections was to purge his very life, then his nature would dictate that he do so.

For Abraham to commit such an act, however, required that he rise above his own character as a ‘chesed’ person and act contrary to his way of serving God. To do so would be possible only if his faith were so great that he was capable of acting counter to everything he had understood and believed.

Abraham showed that his devotion came above all other considerations. He injected his unconditional faith into the national character so that no matter how encrusted Israel may become with sin, and no matter how much it fell in line with sin’s fleeting pleasures, there remains the spark of Abraham’s holiness within every son and daughter of Israel. Repentance, therefore, is an ever present possibility if, somehow, that spark can be reached and fanned. The basic urge of Abraham’s children is to be righteous.

III. Trial Intensified

So Abraham’s very nature, as opposed to Isaac’s, dictated that the Akeidah was more his test than his son’s. But the trial was intensified further by the way it was presented. Let’s compare the command of the Akeidah with the command to drive Ishmael from his home. There, God commanded Abraham to follow the superior insight of Sarah. He told him to feel no regret at dispatching the boy, and what is more, He promised Abraham that Ishmael would become a nation for, although only Isaac would have the status of Abraham’s true offspring, Ishmael would still be treated graciously as someone born of Abraham’s seed. Combined with the command that Abraham go against his nature by cutting off his kindness to Ishmael and Hagar, was the assurance that no harm would befall them and that Sarah’s insistence was an expression of God’s own wisdom.

What assurance was he given with regard to the slaughter of Isaac? Was he told that Isaac did not deserve the mantle of Patriarch?.. that he had sinned?… that another would take his place?… that he should cease loving him? NO…

Chapter 22:2 ~ ‘Take your son”…. Isaac remains your son ~ his status is undiminished.”

‘Your only son’ …. He remains unique. Ishmael cannot return to take his place. You were promised a son, and Isaac will always remain the fulfillment of that promise even after you slaughter him.

‘Whom you love’… Continue to love him. Do not take the easy way of convincing yourself that your love was misplaced, that Isaac is unworthy either of your love or of carrying on your mission.

When God uttered those words to Abraham, the Patriarch was infused with a new and greater realization of what Isaac was. His son for whom he had waited a lifetime and for whom all the covenants and promises were made … the bearer of Abraham’s mission … the fulfillment of creation. He was Abraham’s only son. He was unique … there was none like him … he had forged a new way to serve God and no one could take his place.

Abraham loved Isaac. God now confirmed that love and when Abraham heard the words ‘whom you love’, he was infused with a greater love for Isaac than he had ever felt before. Abraham was not to ascend to Mount Moriah with the thought that, little though he understood why, he was removing an unworthy outgrowth of himself. No. He was to go with all the love, respect, expectation, and feeling that an Abraham could possibly feel for an Isaac. He was to go with the realization that Isaac was not expendable and replaceable, neither as a son nor as a Patriarch. And still he was to go. Only by attempting feebly to imagine how difficult God made the trial can we hope to understand how great was the aged father who sought no way to delay or reinterpret, who arose early and with a cheerful willingness to make even the exhausting physical preparations himself.

Faith in the Creator need not supply instant gratification. God need not spell out His reasons and campaign for approval. It is for us to understand that we need not understand. What He wills is right even if our every instinct cries out against it; what He inflicts is merciful even if its immediate result is agony; what He desires is exalting even if its immediate result is despair.

Abraham forged on and his steps etched an eternal path in the history of his children. For if Abraham followed God’s command lovingly even when He was distant, then He would maintain His love for Abraham’s children even when they were spiritually distant and treated badly by people in power. Therefore, too, there remains an inextinguishable spark of love in every Jew. There is a piece of Abraham in every one of his children. It was this remnant that God promised to preserve when he told Abraham, ‘I am your shield’ (15:1), and it is for this eternal pledge that we bless God in our daily prayers saying, ‘Blessed are You, Hashem, Shield of Abraham.’ Not merely for the protection He afforded Abraham ages ago do we bless God. We thank Him for protecting the Abraham within us, the Abrahamic spark of love and devotion that no tidal waves of materialism, oppression, and emancipation can ever extinguish.

Abraham’s ordeal is not done. Satan said to Abraham, ‘Tomorrow God will call you a murderer!’ Abraham replied, ‘Even so, I will do His will’. (Midrash)

Abraham did not even pray for God’s mercy upon Isaac. For the sake of the perversely wicked people of Sodom, Abraham had made a forceful protest to God, but for his own righteous son, he said not a word.

Abraham prayed for Sodom because his chesed character could not endure the destruction of the cities with their people. His prayer was not a personal one, he did not specifically ask for salvation of Lot, his nephew. He begged for heavenly mercy upon the Sodomite sinners because his perception of God was derived from and based upon mercy.

But for Isaac he could not pray just as he did not pray for Lot. To do so would have meant to pray for a selfish interest. No matter how much he might purify his motives and remove all sense of self from his prayer, no matter how much he would base his plea upon the righteousness of Isaac and the destiny of Israel, he was human and his prayer might well be colored ever so slightly with a selfish plea for Isaac, his own son. To whatever extent that were true, it would not be outer-directed chesed designed only to fulfill God’s wish. It would be a plea for himself. Who more than Abraham had a ‘right’ to make such a plea? That he did not make it demonstrates more than anything else the greatness of the Patriarch and the reason God never removes the memory of the Akeidah from the balance where the fate of Israel is measured.

IV.  Ashes and Life

  • Leviticus 26:44: “And I shall remember My covenant with Jacob, and also my covenant with Isaac, and also my covenant with Abraham shall I remember.” Why does it not specify remembrance in connection with Isaac? Because (God says) the ashes of Isaac are visible before Me gathered together atop the altar.
  • How did they (the Men of the Great Assembly) know where to build the altar (of the Second Temple?…’They saw the ashes of Isaac laying on that place’. (Zevachim 62a)

Isaac’s ashes lay before God. They identify the altar because the Sages knew that the altar of the Temple was built upon the site of Abraham’s altar on Mount Moriah. But how can the Sages speak of Isaac’s ashes when Isaac was never sacrificed and burned. There can be no ashes if Isaac who never became an actual sacrifice, yet the legally specified placement of the altar was determined by the ‘ashes of Isaac.’ A strange paradox! Isaac lived, but his ashes mark the pace of his sacrifice.

Both Abraham and Isaac came with all their hearts to complete the offering. There was no hesitation, no attempt to seek a reprieve. In every sense, except the physical, Abraham did slaughter Isaac and burn his remains as an offering.

No human being had ever done as Isaac did. He truly became Abraham’s offering. He mounted the altar and the knife was at his throat. It took a Divine Command to gain his release. When he descended the altar, he was no less an offering than he was when he ascended it. The ram was his substitute in an even more tangible way than even the purest sacrifice that would ever be brought in fulfillment of God’s command, because it took Isaac’s place on the altar. The ashes of the ram were on the altar in the place of Isaac’s. Thus, the ashes of the ram were Isaac’s in a very real sense.

We must remember that there are two very different worlds: the spiritual world and the physical world. In a higher world, Isaac surely can be seen as ashes. His willingness to become a sacrifice never left God’s cognizance. The spiritual effect of his deed remained imprinted on the top of Mount Moriah.

People attuned to spirituality see things that others don’t see. When Abraham and Isaac approached the mountain, they knew without being told that they had found the place. The saw a beautiful mountain covered by a pillar of smoke – the Shechinah. Their two attendants looked at the same mountain and saw only deserts. Were all four in the same place? Geographically, yes. But in the truest sense they were worlds apart. Abraham and Isaac were at the mountain of God and Ishamael and Eliezer were in the Canaanite desert. From that perspective, the participation of Abraham and Isaac at the Akeidah created his ashes, for he was truly sacrificed in every world but the material one. And in the material world, the ram took his place.

God promised to remember the covenant with Abraham and Jacob, but there was no need to bring the covenant of Isaac back from the past. Isaac’s ashes were before Him always, a living reminder of Isaac’s covenant – because an ascent to such spiritual heights as the Akeidah never dies.

Therefore, too, Isaac’s life after the Akeidah was of a different order than any other. He was a living sacrifice, sanctified and spiritual. For that reason, he was forbidden to leave the Land. Abraham had gone to Egypt and Jacob was to go to Charan and Egypt. But when famine struck in Isaac’s time, God ordered him not to leave Eretz Yisrael; he was a holy offering ~ and offerings may not leave the holy soil.

When the Akeidah was over, Abraham sent Isaac to the Academy of Shem to study Torah, for he said, ‘Whatever I have attained is only because of the Torah, therefore I want it to remain with my children forever.’ (Midrash)

Indeed, Isaac’s life after the Akeidah was different in more than a symbolic way:

  • “When the sword reached Isaac’s neck, his soul left him. When God’s voice came from between the two cherubim telling Abraham not to harm him, his soul returned to his body … Isaac experienced the resuscitation of the dead and said ‘Blessed are You, Hashem, Who makes the dead live!’” (Pesikta d’Rabbi Eliezer 31)

As the Zohar says, the letters of ‘Isaac’ form the words ‘the end of life’. Isaac’s earthly life had truly come to an end. Only the word of God brought his soul back to him. He blessed God for having given him the gift of life anew. His new life was a gift of God; his mortal life had truly ended. Thus, the intention of Abraham and Isaac to offer everything to God was fulfilled. The Isaac who walked away from the Akeidah was not the same one who had come to it. He was even greater than he had been earlier for he had given his life as a gift to God. That earlier life, the earthly one before Isaac became a sacrifice, merged with the ashes of the ram, ashes that never leave the notice of God.

Strangely, the name chosen for that climactic even hardly seems to symbolize its true essence, Akeidah Yitzchock, the binding of Isaac. True, upon placing himself upon the altar, Isaac asked his father to bind him tight lest he interfere with the knife-stroke by inadvertently moving, thereby rendering the sacrifice unfit, but that is so minor an aspect of the incident that it hardly seems appropriate to base the title of the event upon it. Sacrifice of Isaac! Slaughter of Isaac! Gift of Isaac! Selflessness of Isaac! Why ‘binding of Isaac’?

However, the name was well chosen indeed, for the very triviality it expressed reveals the greatness of Isaac.

Abraham and Isaac walked together for three days. We can imagine the turbulence in the heart of Abraham who knew why they were going, and the serenity of Isaac who thought that he would join with his father in offering an animal on the holy mountain of the future Temple. How different their feelings must have been! But the Torah testifies that ‘the two of them went together’ (22.6). Together they went, equal in resolve ~ equal in serenity ~ one to bind and the other to be bound; one to slaughter and the other to be slaughtered (Midrash). Neither thought of tragedy, only of the Creator Whose will they were going to perform.

Then Isaac learned of his destiny. ‘You are the ‘sheep’ my son!’ And again (22:8) ‘the two of them went together’. Now it was Isaac who should have been broken and depressed, but it wasn’t. The mood remained the same. The only thing that mattered was God’s will ~ whatever form it’s fulfillment would take.

It was enough of Isaac that he volunteer himself as a sacrifice. Surely he could not have had the presence of mind to worry about details. Few are the people who can maintain their calm in trying circumstances. The true test is not how one reacts when the trial comes, for a person is not himself when he is struck by tragedy. The test is how well he has lived his life in order to be prepared for the crisis. It is too late when the awful moment comes to make preparations or develop the personality to cope with it. Abraham’s response, Isaac’s response, were not born on Mount Moriah. Their reaction had been nurtured within them for years. The trial was no more than the means to reveal what had been present within them.

The measure of Isaac’s greatness was that he was conscious even of the danger that a reflex moment might ruin the slaughter. Of all the things to think of! It was a vital detail, but surely not a noticeable major aspect of the panorama of the trial. How could he be as calm? But he did think of that and he was calm.

Did his life mean so little to him? No, his life was exceedingly important to him because it was the tool with which to serve God, and without his life his service would be over. Life is so precious!! Isaac’s life was precious beyond value, but only because it was the tool with which to serve God. The greatest indication of his greatness is that, in the last moments of his worldly life, he thought not of his last will and testament, of the future generations he would not produce, or of the aged parents whom his loss would bereave. He thought of a reflex action, a sudden movement, a misplace stroke of the knife, a life that might be squandered if it were not returned to its Maker through a proper slaughter.

“Bind me tight lest I move due to fear of the knife and I cause you anguish. And perhaps the slaughter would be unfit and the offering would not be credited to you. Bind me well, very well.”

At such a time, Isaac thought of small things. People can rise up to great occasions and often do ~ even little people! But only the greatest people rise to the smallest needs.

Sodom

When the Jewish nation was crossing the Wilderness on its way to Eretz Yisrael, it was instructed that it must not allow the Seven Nations of Canaan to remain in the Land. Israel was warned that the Land would spew forth its sinful inhabitants.

But there was another element in Eretz Yisrael, one even more wicked than the Seven Nations; a culture even more corrupt than Canaan – Sodom. Despite the abominations that were so intolerable to the very essence of the Land, the Canaanite Nations were permitted to remain there for four hundred and seventy years after Abraham first received title to it at the Covenant Between the Parts. At that time he was told that a four hundred year exile would intervene – one that began with the Birth of Isaac thirty years later. Even thereafter his descendants spent another forty years in the wilderness, before the Canaanite and Amorite quota of sin was reached (Genesis 15:16), but Sodom and its tributary cities were wiped from the earth is an unprecedented manner after only fifty-two years of settlement. The generation of the Flood was wiped out, but the world was rebuilt on its remains. The Generation of the Dispersion was banished and scattered, but it lived to populate and develop the earth. Sodom, on the other hand, was overturned; it’s people were killed, it’s possessions totally destroyed, and its very locale – the rich, grassy plain which had enticed Lot to leave his mentor and protector (13:10-11) – was transformed into the salty, sulphuric wilderness that to this day is called the Dead Sea.

What was it about Sodom?

The cruelties of Sodom have entered the language as the epitome of selfishness, callousness and depravity. But there was a method, a rationale, behind their perverse behavior. Not unless we find the pattern behind their excesses can we understand the extent of their evil and the revulsion God felt for them.

The region of Sodom was rich and fertile. Of all the Land lying before him, Lot chose only Sodom in which to settle and make his fortune. We can well imagine that if it held such a powerful attraction for someone like Lot who, for all his deficiencies, had still been raised by Abraham and Sarah and who was a relatively righteous person as well as a wealthy one, then it must have been even more attractive for thousands of others.

The Sodomites knew this too. And they were the first to devise policies to close their gates to the unwelcome ordinary people who threatened to dilute the economic base and mar the prosperity of the limited, but comfortable population of the region. In effect, Sodom was the originator of anti-immigration laws.

They did more than take down the welcome signs. They made it a terrifying experience for a stranger to even visit Sodom. A traveler would find no door open to him. Not a crust of bread or a drop of water would be offered to him. If he dared to seek lodging, he would be violently tormented, even maimed! The traveler by foot in Sodom would be subject to perverse sexual abuse. The Sodomite who dared violate the social and legal restraints against hospitality would be treated as an enemy of the people and would be subject to abuse even worse than that handed out to the unsuspecting visitor – for, after all, the unwelcome migrant was but an unwitting and relatively harmless annoyance, but the citizen who broke the Sodomite tradition was a corrupting influence and a danger to the social and economic order.

Seeds of Sodom

The Mishnah (Avos 5:10), in describing attitudes toward follow humans, says: “The one who says ‘What is mine is mine and what is yours is yours’ (i.e., he wishes neither to give to nor to receive from others) – this is the manner of ordinary people. Some say it is the manner of Sodom.”

The Sages have given us an insight into the source of Sodomite iniquity and at the same time a sobering lesson in the evaluation of our own behavior. We are not surprised to read that ‘the manner of ordinary people’ calls for one neither to give nor to receive. ‘Neither lender nor borrower be’ has come into the language as a well-accepted maxim of conduct. This runs counter to the Torah’s teaching that a Jew is required to lend and to give – nevertheless, it is hardly a code of conduct that can be described as wicked. Therefore, the first opinion cited by the Mishnah describes it as the code of ordinary people: it shows little sensitivity to the needs of others, but one would prefer it to the grasping, selfish attitude that has been the cause of suffering and misery throughout history.

The second opinion sees it differently. In itself, the code is not evil, but what seeds of wickedness it contains. Sodom, too, began as a society that said ‘what is mine is mine and what is yours is yours’. Sodom was not an aggressive, warrior nation that plundered its neighbors. To the contrary, the one time in Scripture where we find Sodom engaged in battle, they were humiliated in defeat (14:10-11). But Sodom was concerned in protecting what it had and in not sharing it with others. To do so, it erected a new social code, one that did not stop with ‘charity begins at home’, but which erected barriers against the unfortunate, terror against the helpless, that pronounced a sentence of a slow and painful death upon a girl whose only crime was that she secretly gave a crust of bread to a hungry stranger. People can go to frightening lengths to protect ‘legitimate interests.’ The person or nation whose eyes turn inward in selfish concern for the protection of only his own concerns, should search long and hard lest he become a Sodomite.

Unforgivable Sin

In the eyes of God, the greatest abomination of all is a social contract founded on selfishness, descending to cruelty, resulting in perversion of decency. Licentiousness is a grievous sin because of it the nations of Canaan were vomited out of the Land, and Israel was warned against it in the harshest terms. But it is understandable that human beings, possessed of animal passions, may fail to control them. Even a selfish unwillingness to help others is understandable. But to erect a society with a social and legal code in defense of selfishness and in opposition to kindness – that is an abomination which both in God’s eyes and in Jewish tradition is described with the contemptuous epithet – ‘the manner of Sodom.’ That behavior, God will not tolerate. It resulted in the total upheaval that left no trace of the period’s wealthiest city.

Indeed, the people of Sodom, unanimously and brazenly, acted to oppose the elementary dictates of decency, for that reason they could not be endured nor permitted to survive. The property of Canaan was neither destroyed nor forbidden: the property of Sodom was removed from the face of the earth, so grievous was their sin.

Would the same thing have happened if Sodom had been in Africa, Europe or America? Most assuredly not. The sin would have been grievous, and it would have been punished somehow and at some time. But the Sodomites committed their blight in Eretz Yisrael, the Land of holiness, the land which cannot abide sin. A sin there is worse. In the words of Ramban:

  • “Know that the judgment of Sodom was due to the spiritual elevation of Eretz Yisrael, for it is the inheritance of God and it does not tolerate abominable people. Just as it would later vomit out the entire nation (of Canaan) because of their abomination, it preceded and vomited out this nation (Sodom) which was the worst of all, to heaven and to humans, and rained desolation upon it from heaven and earth, and ravaged the land beyond cure forever. For they were haughty because of their prosperity, and God saw that it (the total destruction of the selfish society) would be an omen for rebellious people, for Israel which was destined to inherit it (the Land) ….. For there are among the nations very wicked and sinful people, but He did not (utterly destroy) them. But (He did so to Sodom) because of the spiritual elevation of Eretz Yisrael for it is the Temple of Hashem (Genesis 19:5).”

Genesis 17:1-2 The Importance of Blood Covenant

Understanding the importance of covenant will revolutionize your fellowship with the Father and create a foundation of trust in Him and the authority of His WORD. Understanding the reality and absolute bedrock of your covenant with Almighty God will cause your faith to grow by leaps and bounds to new dimensions of strength and confidence.

Ancient people knew the significance and power of covenant. Webster’s Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary defines covenant as a “usually formal, solemn, and binding agreement or promise usually under seal between two or more parties, especially for the performance of some action.” This sounds like our modern word contract, but many of today’s agreements are easily broken and often not worth the ink with which they are written.

A true blood covenant, like those understood and entered into by tribal societies, was a finding agreement: “until death do us part.” Even then, the commitment could last up to eight generations. But in Deuteronomy 7:9 God promised to keep His covenant and mercy with those who love Him and keep His commandments to a thousand generations. Through the eternal power of the blood of Jesus, our new covenant, based on better promises is forever sealed!

After Adam’s treason, God’s intense and unconditional love (Hebrew: hesed; Greek: agape) went into action with the eternal plan of redemption that was in the mind of God from the foundation of the world (Revelation 13:8; 1 Peter 1:18-20). He put into motion His plan to rescue man from his illegitimate stepfather, satan, to whom Adam had bowed his knee and yielded his God-given authority through disobedience (Luke 4:6; John 8:34;, Romans 6:16). In Genesis 17 we see God’s reaching out to a man named Abram and receiving permission to enter into a binding agreement with him.

God promised Abram to be a God to him and his seed and to bless and multiply him exceedingly (Genesis 17:2). He promised Abram land and that his barren ninety-year-old wife would have a son, through whose seed all the nations of the earth would be blessed (Genesis 18:18). He then bound Himself to Abram through the power of a blood covenant.

In a covenant, promises are made on both sides, names are exchanged, and the whole transaction is sealed in blood. Abram shed his blood through circumcision – the seal of his covenant with God. Since God is a Spirit (John 4:24), He had Abram shed the blood of animals to ratify His part of the covenant (Genesis 15:9-10). Then, according to true covenant rules, He gave Abram a new name – a covenant name. He called him Abraham, “the father of nations”, inserting a letter from His own Name (‘h’ Hebrew ‘hey’ from YHWH) into the middle of Abraham’s name. He did the same with Abraham’s wife’s name, Sarai, who then became Sarah: “mother of nations.” God then swore by Himself (Hebrews 6:13-17) to uphold the covenant, since there is none greater than He.

After Isaac, the son of promise, was miraculously conceived and born to a ninety-year-old woman and a one-hundred-year-old man, God asked Abraham to sacrifice Isaac, through whom Abraham had been told his descendants would be as the sand of the seashore and the stars of the sky in multitude. Abraham obeyed: “He reasoned that God was able to raise him up, even from the dead; from which he indeed received him in a figurative sense” (Hebrews 11:19). Abraham was fully persuaded his covenant Partner would uphold His end of the covenant (Romans 4:20-21). He told the young men who accompanied them to the site, “Stay here with the donkey. The boy and I will go over there and worship and then return to you” (Genesis 22:5). Because of Abraham’s covenant with God and his faith and willingness to sacrifice his son, the way was paved for God, his covenant Partner, to sacrifice His Son. The way made for Jesus, the spotless, eternal covenant sacrifice, to legally come into the earth to redeem mankind.

When you receive revelation of the absolute, final authority of God’s covenant WORD, sealed in the eternal blood of Jesus, a new and unshakable confidence rises up in your heart that God’s unchanging WORD stands rock-solid, forever. Psalm 119:89 says, “Forever, O Lord, Your word is established in heaven.” It is guaranteed in heaven’s eternal integrity.

Jesus, the Lamb of God, the WORD made flesh, said, “Heaven and earth will pass away but My Words will never pass away” (Matthew 24:35; Mark 13:31; Luke 21:33). And Hebrews 6:17-19, further revealing the steadfastness and unchangeableness of God’s Word, says, “So God, wanting to show more abundantly the immutability (Unchangeableness) of His counsel to the heirs of promise, confirmed it by an oath. So that by two immutable things, in which it was impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuse might have strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us. We have this hope as a sure and steadfast anchor of the soul, which enters the inner Place behind the veil.”

Unlike the old covenant that depended on His people’s ability to keep it, the new covenant, now between God the Father and Jesus (Galatians 3:16-20), can never be broken. You are in Christ Jesus by the new birth, made a joint heir with Him – forever bound, by faith, into this unchangeable and eternal covenant. When you believe and rely on the steadfastness and integrity of God’s unchanging WORD to you, nothing can stop the fulfillment of His promises. The believer who knows and stands on his covenant with the living God, like Abraham, can confidently stake his life on the integrity of his covenant Partner’s WORD, knowing that Almighty God has sworn by Himself in the blood of His own Son. The words of this eternal covenant are activated by faith, so if you’ll believe it, receive it, and act on it, it will surely come to pass!

This is from an article written in the Kenneth Copeland Study Bible.

Eretz Yisrael – The Supremacy of the Land

     “Whoever lives in Eretz Yisrael is like one who has a God, and whoever lives outside the Land is like one who has no God (Kesuvos 110b).”

I.  The Perception of Holiness

The universe is full of God’s glory. Everything proclaims it from the mightiest galaxy to the frailest blade of grass to the sub-microscopic organism. Can one even imagine that God is limited to the Temple Mount or the Holy Land? But human beings are trapped in a material world that obscures His existence and they must grope to find traces and rays of the holiness that is everywhere.

So.. where is God? He is everywhere, but some people see and others don’t. And some places more readily provide the spiritual illumination for those who wish to see.

Of all the countries on earth, Eretz Yisrael is uniquely suited to the perception of holiness. Whoever lives outside Eretz Yisrael is ‘like’ one who has no God. Lacking the holy atmosphere of the Land, the conditions created by God to serve as the habitat for His Temple and His prophets, a person may fail to see the Godliness in every aspect of his existence.

This is what our Sages mean when they say that one who lives in Eretz Yisrael is ‘like’ one who has a God, but one who lives outside the Land is ‘like’ one who is Godless. The key word is ‘like’. Both have a God. Every person has a God and He is everywhere. But there is a place where He is easily accessible to all who seek, a place where, because people find Him, He is present. That place is the Land whose very atmosphere conveys the wisdom of fear of God, whose hills and valleys echo with the footsteps of the Patriarchs, the words of the prophets – the handiwork of Him Who said, ‘Let there be a universe.’ One who lives in Eretz Yisrael and allows his spiritual eyes to remain open – sees; one who lives outside the Land denies himself that unique perception. Compared to the one who basks in its holiness and sees the hand of God caressing every blade of grass and infusing every thought, he is ‘like’ one who has no God.

Every huiman being was created with his own set of talents and handcaps, they are the tools give him to carry out his spiritual mission. His measure of potential is uniquely his, it is the measure of holiness which he was created to reveal and thus contribute to the fulfillment of the universe. Since Eretz Yisrael is symbolic of the recognition of God, every Jew has a share in Eretz Yisrael. For, in essence, Eretz Yisrael is not a geographical entity; its mountains and valleys, plains and seas, are but the physical manifestations of its spiritual being. It is a Holy Land because it is a Land of Holiness. Every Jew is charged with bring to fruition his portion of holiness, his own Eretz Yisrael, wherever on earth he lives. Therefore, our Sages taught the legal principle that “There is no man who does not have four cubits in Eretz Yisrael (Bava Basra 44b).

Even the Jew who has never set foot in Eretz Yisrael, much less purchased a lot of its land, is considered the owner of four cubits (the minimum amount of space in which a person can function)(Bava Mezia 10a). The Sages understood that if the Jew can only attain his highest level of spiritual attainment in Eretz Yisrael, then it is inconceivable that part of the Land is not his. This being so, the principle that the Holy Land allows the Jew to develop his spiritual capacities to their maximum dictates that every Jew have his share in Eretz Yisrael. And because each person is an individual with a potential like no other, his own four cubits are his, and none other’s. Exactly where in Eretz Yisrael those particular square inches are does not matter – they are his!

Understood this way, much that the Sages have taught takes on deeper significance and meaning. Over the course of his lifetime, man is presented with many opportunities. Each is a test.

The person raised to a new position enters a new realm of responsibility and judgment. The old standards no longer apply. If he rises to the occasion with a new sense of dedication and the prayer that he not fall short of the challenge presented him, then he indeed merits that his earlier sins be forgiven. His new position was the cause of repentance. His old world disappeared when he was elevated to a new dimension of responsibility. The first accomplishment of the new mantle was to change the person upon whom it fell. He has changed, grown, repented – and so his sins are forgiven.

But if he fails to discharge his new responsibilities properly, he is held responsible for the lack of accomplishment that resulted from his negligence. The emperor who fiddles while his city burns is not judged by the quality of his concerto. He is held responsible for the destruction of homes and the ruin of lives, and for the tragedy of human resources squandered on the clearing of rubble when they could have been building palaces.

He who was granted the privilege of living in Eretz Yisrael has the challenge of utilizing the capacity it provides him for spiritual growth. Being there is a challenge, and like all challenges, it carries with it the possibility of success – or failure. As in all matters of the spirit, God provides an even balance. Opportunity is equal with pitfall. The enormous good that can be done by one who is elevated to greatness – good of such enormity that it can wipe away his sins and set him in a new world – is balanced by the evil that becomes his responsibility if he fails to meet the challenge – or if he misuses his new power.

Rav Saadia Gaon says that Israel without Torah, is like a body without a soul; we may say the same of Eretz Yisrael: without the observance of the commandments, it, too, is like a body without a soul. But when it is host to a people that obeys the word of God, the potential of the Land is unlimited.

The Khuzari goes on to portray the greatness of the Land. Every prophet prophesied either in it or concerning it – otherwise, no matter how great the person, he could not hear the world of God. Cain and Abel contended over Eretz Yisrael; the brother chosen by God would gain the gift of prophesy and possession of the Land, the other would be subservient to him like the shell of a fruit. And when Cain, murderer of his brother, was banished from the Presence of Hashem (4:16), it was from Eretz Yisrael that he was forced to go, for God’s Presence is in His Chosen Land. Ishmael’s strife with Isaac was over the same inheritance, and so was Esau’s with Jacob. In Eretz Yisrael the Patriarchs erected their altars, and there God heard their prayers. Atop its Mount Moriah Abraham bound his son to the altar, the same mountain where David built an altar and where the Holy Temple stood and will stand again. And just as a farmer who finds a lovely tree in the wilderness will tenderly dig it up and transplant it in his finest soil, so too, when God found a treasure in Ur Kasdim and Charan, he brought him to Eretz Yisrael, tested him, found him worthy, sealed a covenant with him, made him father of His chosen nation, and gave him a new name, Abraham. Great though he was, even Abraham could not achieve fulfillment until he was brought to Eretz Yisrael.

II.  The Unforgiving Land

Because Eretz Yisrael is so saturated with holiness, it demands higher standards of behavior than does any other corner of earth. Just as Israel’s nature is unlike that of any other people, so the nature of its Land is unlike that of any other. Ramban deals at length with this phenomenon. The following exposition is taken almost in its entirety from his commentary to Leviticus 18:25.

After citing the full catalog of forbidden immorality (Leviticus 18:1-24), the Torah strongly urged Israel not to defile itself with these offenses, for the Canaanite inhabitants of the Land had done so with the result that “The Land became impure, and I recalled its sin for it and the Land vomited out its inhabitants” (verse 25).

Israel was warned not to imitate the Canaanite abominations lest it too defile the land and be vomited out by it (verses 26-30). The verses are truly striking. Israel is warned against immorality not merely because it defiles Israel’s own holy nature and deviates its mission as the Chosen People of God, it cannot abide immoral inhabitants and because the Land will expel immoral inhabitants just as they body vomits putrid food. The implication is clear – sin is forbidden everywhere, but in the Eretz Yisrael it is worse.

The same is true of Israel, the nation. Israel is judged by a double standard. It is God’s nation and He demands more of it. It cannot complain that it is judged more harshly than the nations for the same sins for its greatness demands that it adhere to higher standards than they. By the same token, its rewards for fulfilling its obligations as the children of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, as the nation that stood at Sinai and accepted the Torah, are higher – no! they are of an entirely different order – than those of any other nation no matter how pious and noble it may be. For the Land and the Nation share one unique characteristic – they are the special province of God.

The Patriarchs recognized this connection. Their souls were so attuned to holiness that they could sense the affect of every deed. They knew that upon arising in the morning, one must accept upon himself the yoke of God’s kingdom, that different species were not to be mixed, that work was not to be done on Sabbath, that certain marriages were incestuous. They complied with the entire Torah before it was given to Israel.

Israel was commanded, exhorted, and warned to be moral in it’s Land. The expulsion of the Canaanites was not in punishment for their immorality. Egypt, too, was immoral, and Israel was instructed to avoid their lack of moral restraints which were no less than those of Canaan (Leviticus 18:3). But no matter how much the immorality of Egypt may have been a factor in the plagues and punishment, its land did not vomit out sinners. Only Eretz Yisrael did that.

The fate of the seven nations of Caanan was sealed long before Joshua’s armies carried out God’s command to decimate them. They had long since been doomed: the Torah says, the Land vomited (past tense) its inhabitants (Leviticus 18:25). Their immorality had condemned them; Israel was but the vehicle to carry out the decree. Had it not been Israel’s time to enter its Promised Land, we may be certain that some other nation would have driven out the Canaanites. It was the Land that could not endure them, just as the Land would expel sinful Israel from its midst in the tragic days of Jeremiah and Ezekiel. For the Land of Israel on earth and Jerusalem on earth are reflections of Eretz Yisrael and Jerusalem on high. They are not geographical points on a map, but physical manifestations of spiritual levels. One does not commit immoral acts in heaven; one does not commit immoral acts on heaven on earth.

The entire story of creation is beyond human comprehension. After reading the story of the first week of human history can we claim even a vague understanding of the process by which a vacuum was transformed into the universe? Nevertheless, God gave us the Torah, including the narrative of creation, and the succeeding story of mankind’s sins, punishments, conquests, migrations, and most importantly, the story of Abraham and his offspring. The entire Book of Genesis and the first eleven chapters of Exodus, fully sisty-one chapters in a Book, where every word, letter, and even the ‘crowns of letters’ are dissected for meaning and interpretation – all of this was transmitted to man only to make unmistakably clear that the Master of the Universe destined a corner of His creation for His nation. In early times it might be occupied by the Canaanites and Emorites. Later it would become the conquest of Babylonians, Romans. Moslems, Christians, Arabs, Turks, Britons. The catalogue of conquerors could be long and varied, but the Owner of the Land remains He Who created it. It was He alone Who could determine its destiny, and in His Torah He made clear that it would be the possession of Israel and none other.

A not insignificant measure of Israel’s tragic history is how much of its existence has been spent exiled from its Land. The nineteen centuries of the current exile alone are longer than the total number of years that Israel was true sovereign of all its Land. But even during the bitterest years of exile, there was no more eloquent testimony to Israel’s eternal ownership of that slim strip of heaven on earth than the Land itself – the very Land that had banished, regurgitated, Israel as unworthy of its sanctity – that very Land testified that Israel is the single nation on earth that can claim title to its hills and valleys. “And I will lay the Land waste, and upon it, your enemies who inhabit it will be desolate” (Leviticus 26:32).

The Land that expelled Israel would welcome none other. Your enemies will inhabit your Land, but they will be desolate upon it. The Land that flowed with milk and honey for Israel would become dry and bitter. Valleys that were lush, plains that were green, would turn to wasteland and desert. No nation would find prosperity there. The grieving Land would wrap itself tight in its mourning shroud and refuse to nurse the children that came to replace her own. She would weep and wait.

No nation has ever succeeded in Eretz Yisrael – except for the Jews. The reason is clearly given by the Torah: the Land is Israel’s. For Israel it will flow with milk and honey. Let Israel fall short of its mandate, and the Land will expel it, but even when that happens, it will withhold its blessings from any other claimant.

Abraham could not even receive God’s blessings and covenant until he was in Eretz Yisrael. While he was still a resident of Charan at the age of seventy, he made a brief trip to Eretz Yisrael where God appeared to him and made the Covenant Between the Pieces. Abraham returned to his father’s home and was not bidden to make the final break with his past until five years later when he was commanded to go to the land which God would show him. Despite his already proven greatness, Abraham could not even receive God’s promise anywhere but in the Holy Land, much less begin the long process of laying the foundation for the Chosen People.

Indeed, the first time Abraham journeyed to Eretz Yisrael, he was not bidden by God to do so. He himself perceived the holiness of the Land and wished to be in it. Later, when God bid him to break with his homeland and family and travel ‘to the land which I will show you’ (12:1), Abraham immediately set out for Eretz Yisrael; he knew that it was God’s country and he believed implicitly that God could have meant no other place.

There is a way, albeit an imperfect one, to experience the exaltation of the Land even though one cannot be within it. The firm resolve to live as holy a life as humanly possible and the strong desire to live it as if one were truly on the sacred soil can be considered in some measure equivalent to being there. May this inspiring thought help elevate our thoughts and deeds until the time when hope and reality merge.

The Tests

     “Our father Abraham was tested with ten trials and he withstood them all, demonstrated how great was Abraham’s love (for God) (Avos 5:3).”

I.  Purpose of Trials

What is the purpose of a trial?

God knows what a person will and will not do. He knows a person’s capabilities. Further, the Sages teach that a person is never tested beyond his capabilities: the implication is that a divine test is inflicted only upon people of already proven greatness. Clearly, God inflicts trials for a purpose that goes far beyond one’s normal life-experience. The businessman who takes a crushing loss or forgoes a huge profit because he, and no one else, knows that the profitable course of action will violate an obscure clause in the Shulchan Aruch (Code of Jewish Law), will surely be rewarded. He is to be admired, respected, and emulated; but his temptation and triumph do not fall within the category of ‘trial’ which was the lot of the Patriarchs. Abraham, for example, was an immensely wealthy man who surely had business dealings of all varieties. He had as much opportunity as the next man for sharp dealing, even dishonesty; yet such matters are not included among his ten trials. The concept of ‘trial’ as used with relation to the Patriarchs goes infinitely deeper than the mere need to cope with the normal twists and challenges of life.

King David was told that he was inferior to the spiritual level of the Patriarchs because they had been tested while he had not been. Yet the agony of David’s life is graphically and poignantly portrayed in the Book of Samuel, the verses of Psalms, the countless heart-rending Aggadic references to his history. We may well pray that we not face even a fraction of David’s trials – yet his challenges were not considered, trials, in the sense of Abraham’s, Isaac’s and Jacob’s. (Sanhedrin 107a). If David’s life was not a series of tests, than the Torah’s definition of ‘trial’ surely involves more than the clichés of normal existence.

Ramban in introducing Abraham’s climactic trial, the Akeidah of Isaac (see commentaries of chapter 22), explains that the trial is not for God’s benefit, in the sense that a teacher may administer a test to evaluate the performances of a student. That sort of test is for the benefit of the teacher, but God’s test is for the benefit of the person being tested. God already knows what he can and will do. A human being’s primary reward is not for good potential and fine intentions. This world was created to serve as the medium for human free-willed performance, and God’s reward and punishment are reserved primarily for deeds. Just as a person is not punished for a sin he was coerced to do since the lack of free will on his part renders the act null and void in terms of transgression, so too, a good but unfulfilled intention is hardly equivalent to a deed performed. Thus, when God puts a great man to the test, it is in order to permit him to translate potential into reality so that he becomes even greater for having overcome obstacles in the service of God and so that he can be rewarded for the performance itself.

  • Know that Hashem tests (only) the righteous; when he knows that the Tzaddik will do His will and He wishes to benefit him, He will command him (to undergo) the trial. But He will not test the wicked who will not obey. Behold, therefore, that all trials in the Torah are for the benefit of the one being tested. (Ramban 22:1)

Sforno adds that God wants the righteous to demonstrate in deed their love for and fear of God, for by translating their feelings into action they emulate God Himself Whose merciful deeds are continuing and endless. By realizing their great potential, the righteous fulfill the purpose of creation – which was that man should emulate God as much as possible.

As many commentators note, the word trial, is related to a banner, which was raised up high. The purpose of a trial is not to test in the usual sense of the word – and most assuredly it is not intended as a trap for the inadequate; if it were, the wicked would be tested – rather the trial is meant to ‘raise up’ the righteous by lifting them to new spiritual heights. Every person has observed countless times that someone who successfully survived the crucible of difficult experience emerges a better person. The lecturer, teacher, cook, mechanic, driver – no matter what field, the one who turns theory into practice in difficult situations becomes a superior master of his craft. Great though Abraham already was, he became greater with each triumphant surmounting of a new trial. This, indeed, was the purpose of a trial – not to prove to God what He already knew, but to raise the subject to new heights just as a banner is lifted higher and higher on its pole.

As Abarbanel notes, a banner has other functions as well. It is meant to be an affirmation of identity, to hold the loyalties of its adherents, and to warn enemies to maintain their distance. Who would have known what the Patriarchs were capable of doing had they not been tested? And once they emerged as God’s proven champions, they became ‘banners’ proclaiming to all the world that human beings are capable of attaining heights exalted beyond prior imagination. And if mortals could accomplish so much, then why shouldn’t everyone aspire to reach above his imagined limitations? As our Sages taught, a person should always say, “When will my deeds touch the deeds of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob?”

Maharal (Avos 5:3) derives ‘trial’ from ‘miracle The nature of a miracle is that it is supernatural. That the Patriarchs could withstand the trials imposed upon them was entirely miraculous. Human beings should not have succeeded. That is why David failed when at his insistence, he was tested with the temptation of Bathsheba (Sanhedrin 107a). Yet the trials of the Patriarchs, though surely difficult, do not seem to us to be unendurable. Even the climatic trial, the Akiedah, however awesome, has not gone unduplicated. How many Jewish parents have sacrificed everything to sanctify God’s Name? But, as we shall now see, even that awesome degree of devotion is a direct result of Abraham’s readiness to sacrifice even Isaac.

II.  The Nation is Formed

As explained in the Overview of the Patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob were not limited to themselves as individuals. Rather, they set patterns that became part of the national grain. Clearly, the character traits of the Patriarchs were engraved in the national genes, so to speak – this, too, was part of the process of forming a profound and ever lasting influence so that the deeds of the Patriarchs were a sign for the children.

Rabbi Chaim infers this principle from the words of the Mishnah. In telling of the ten failed generations from Noah to Abraham, the Mishnah does not refer to Abraham, our Father (Avos 5:2-3). The inference to be drawn is that the trials endured by Abraham were part of the patrimony he bequeathed to his children. He endured them as the Father of the nation, not as a great and righteous individual.

As King Solomon wrote, “When a tzaddik proceeds in his wholesomeness, praises go to his children after him. (Proverbs 20:7). Many are the traits that a tzaddik acquires only through the hard, unremitting labor of character perfection – by conquering the most unforgiving of enemies: himself! But to his children after him, they are second nature.

When the Sages insist that we take as models the deeds of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, they urge an attainable goal. Not, of course, that any of us can actually become even remotely as great as they were, but that our deeds can ‘touch’ theirs, because our deeds grow out of the seeds they planted just as we, ourselves, are their offspring. We need not fear the challenge of greatness because the ground has been broken by the Patriarchs and we are blossoms of their tree.

The trials of the Patriarchs were branded indelibly into Israel’s character that faith comes above life, and that if death must come, it will be accepted with invigorated faith in God because it is but a trial that will raise us like a banner proclaiming that we are children of Abraham. It remains with us and became part of us because God imposed it and the Patriarchs survived it in order to chisel a new trait into the eternity of Israel.

Abraham could have protested. But did not…He did not question or complain. Whatever God willed was good, and if he did not understand why, the deficiency was his. Only the wicked who have earned adversity complain when it comes. The righteous do not complain for they know that human affairs are guided by an Intelligence higher than theirs and by a Compassion unfathomable even to an Abraham.

III. The Cycle of Ten

Chapter five of Avos lists a series of historical phenomena that are numbeed in sets of ten. God created the universe with ten utterances, there were ten generations from Adam to Noah, another ten from Noah to Abraham, the ten trials of Abraham and so on. Ten denotes perfection – represents a development from beginning to completion.

As we have seen in the previous Overview of the Patriarchs, Abraham replaced Adam as the spiritual father of humanity, the one through whom God’s purpose in the universe would be realized and through whom Israel would become the nation selected to receive the Torah. The ideal order of creation began with the realization created by the first utterance: In the Beginning. That utterance was the clear indication that before God began His creative labor there was nothing save for God Himself. Thus, In the Beginning represents the realization that every facet of existence stemmed from His word and will.

From that initial realization, creation went from stage to stage until it reached its culmination with the creation of man whose task it was to bring God’s word into even the minutest aspect of the world. When man was created, however, everything with all its potential of beclouding his senses and obscuring the source of it all was already in place. If mankind knew Who spoke the first utterance, then each succeeding stage represented a further glorification of the One Who could create an universal so multi-faceted. If, however, man saw before him a universe without God, then each succeeding step in creation further obscured the Source. In order for him to comprehend the message of the Ten Utterances, he would have to start from the lowest stage of spiritual recognition and work his way upward. Only after having dismissed each succeeding level of obscurity could he stand at the summit of his spiritual potential and proclaim that God is Master of the universe.

When Abraham began his life of recognizing and proclaiming God, man had fallen from the understanding of creation through two successive ten-generation plunges into the spiritual abyss. The Ten Trials were designed to raise Abraham to ever higher levels of greatness until he stood at the level of ‘In the Beginning’.

The first test was in Ur Kasdim where he defied the institutionalized idolatry of Nimrod’s kingdom and thereby became an enemy of the people. Abraham’s first trial involved a courageous stand – he refused to demean himself by worshipping man’s own handiwork as his god.

Thereby, he proclaimed his humanity, for a man who denies the existence of God forfeits his right to God’s protection and His gifts of life and breath. How can man ever hope to rise above the animal if he fails to acknowledge the sovereignty of his Maker, the source of all spiritual growth? Therefore, Abraham’s first trial established his recognition of the last utterance of creation: ‘Let Us Make Man’. For, indeed, Abraham merited the mantle of Adam.

The eighth trial was circumcision. The surplusage (foreskin) hiding the perfection of man is a barrier to his spiritual advancement. Such barriers must be removed by man and his life must be dedicated to the continued prevention of mundane forces from diluting his spiritual potential. By circumcising himself, Abraham removed from himself the material encumbrance which stood in the way of his spiritual advancement and his attainment of perfection.

The ninth trial was the expulsion of his first-born son Ishmael, together with Hagar. Sarah saw with her superior vision, Ishmael presented a danger to the emergence of Israel, and God instructed Abraham to heed her demand for his expulsion. The second utterance was ‘Let There Be Light’. Ishmael’s presence would have extinguished the merging light of Isaac. By preserving and nurturing that light, Abraham and Sarah attained the level of authentic spiritual light, the light of Torah that illuminates more than do a thousand suns.

The final trial, the AkiedahYitzchak (the Binding of Isaac) brought Abraham to the peak of his fulfillment. He could advance no higher. God said to him, Now I know that you are God-fearing (22:12), for he had been ready to comply with God’s will even if it meant the slaughter of his most cherished possession – the son for whom he had waited so long and who was the guarantor of his future. This recognition that everything was God’s and that nothing stood higher than His will was the living acknowledgment that In the Beginning there was nothing except for Him and that therefore, even after the creation and elaborate development of the universe, there is still nothing except for His will.

IV.  Individual Trials

Everyone’s trial varies according to what he is. For someone to follow his instincts and preferences proves only whether or not his instincts are sound, but it does not prove that his love of God is great enough to lift him above his person desires.

Many of Abraham’s trials involved behavior which ran counter to his generous personality or which would have driven people away from his company. From this perspective we see a new dimension in many of the trials. The command of “Get yourself from your land (12:1), can be seen as a break with family and past, never an easy thing to do for a man of seventy-five. However, it would have been far less difficult for a gevurah-person like Isaac. Abraham had already established a chesed way of life in Charan. He had become a center of spiritual activity; his students numbered in the hundreds and those upon whom he had at least some influence probably ran into the thousands. Now he was to leave the place where he was established and become a stranger in a new land with new customs where he would be forced to begin life anew and develop a network of relationships in order to spread God’s message again. And he was acting cruelly toward his aged father, deserting him at a period in life where he would be needed more rather than less.

The command to dispatch Hagar when she was pregnant, and again later to expel her with Ishmael ran counter to his innermost instincts and the chesed way of service which had become synonymous with his name. How could he drive out people who were part of him, who were dear to him, who were dependent on him and helpless without him?

It is inadequate to see this only in human terms. Abraham had based his service of God on the principle of kindness. How could he reconcile this with cruelty? Circumcision, too, was an act, he feared, that would drive people away from him. The people would consider it bizarre and abnormal. They would sever their relationships with him. The Akiedah, because it was climactic, the greatest of the trials, was also the most complex and difficult of all.   (More of this will be discussed in an overview of the Akeidah)

There is a further aspect of a trial. We know that there are two sides to every story and we have learned, especially in modern times, that an appealing argument can be made for almost any point of view or course of action.

The most ‘irrational’ behavior may be bizarre to the beholder, but the doer may easily consider it proper and even imperative. He may be able to gather up such an overwhelming array of justifications that it may seem useless to engage in discussion much less dispute. Unfortunately, people muster enormous powers of self-deception and rationalization in defense of a course that, once undertaken, must be made to seem logical.

The Patriarchs were not permitted this fallacy. Part of the trial was that Abraham not indulge in the luxury of justifying the required course of action. And Abram went as Hashem told him (12:4): He did not think of the blessings and assurances which God had given him. If Abraham had done that, his obedience would have been selfish. All those thoughts he drove from his mind. He complied with God’s word only because it was God’s will. So it was with every trial, he obeyed because God willed it, not because he understood.

We are part of a tradition. Israel is an old nation whose succeeding generations have laid brick upon brick, but all the bricks are laid atop the foundation that was poured by the Patriarchs. Our reactions to events and sense of national responsibility are predicated upon the lessons of the Torah and the experience of our history. But the Patriarchs had no previously-transmitted Torah and no national experience. They were the originals. They created tradition. They shaped experience. The very title ‘Fathers’, tells what they were. They were our founders and we carry on their mission.

The nature of the trials, and the performance and motives of the Patriarchs in rising to meet them – formed the national character. All the noble strains of intense faith and spiritual exaltation that have ennobled Israel during its almost four thousand years, the determination which has maintained the nation throughout an exile that has far exceeded all its years of national tranquility and independence – these were molded in Ur Kasdim and on Mount Moriah, in Beer Sheba and Hebron, by unquestioning willingness to uproot families and bind children for a slaughter, by readiness to risk unpopularity and provoke hatred, by obeying God’s will even when the obedience seemed to be the direct cause of greater suffering, without doubting for an instant that it was the God of Mercy Who commanded all and a Supreme Intelligence that decreed every event in its minutest detail.

The ‘children’, from David of old to an embattled entrepreneur of today, who follow in those exalted footsteps of old are walking a path that was trodden for them by Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Their manifestations of greatness had no precedent. And when they had finished molding Israel’s character, the period of Fathers ended and the period of children began.

The Patriarchs

The Academy of Eliyahu taught: The world will endure for six thousand years: two thousand (years) of desolation, two thousand of Torah, and two thousand of the Days of Messiah … When did the two thousand of Torah begin? … From (the time of) and the souls whom they (Abraham and Sarah) made (which translates “whom they brought under the yoke of the Torah” (Rashi) in Charan.’ (12:5)

I.  The Emergence

God’s Presence rests upon man to the extent that man permits. If he observes God’s commands only so long as they do not conflict with a particular passion – be it a desire for food, lust, extreme greed for money – then to whatever extent that weakness conflicts with his dedication to the will of God, the Shechinah (the Glory of God) cannot rest upon him. The bearer of God’s Presence is referred to as a ‘chariot’. The Patriarchs are the chariot.

Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are God’s chariot on earth, because it was through them that His Presence descended to earth and found a place here. So great were they that they were able to negate their selves entirely, dedicating every feeling and fiber of their being to His service. Never was there a selfish consideration. Their very existence – every moment of it negated themselves as individuals with rights and desire, they could totally absorb Godliness and thus become bearers – the Chariot – of His Shechinah.

They were the forerunners and the embodiment of the future nation of Israel, and therefore they alone are called Fathers. The twelve tribes, too are ancestors of the nation, but they are not called fathers. Moses was the shepherd, teacher, prophet, most faithful of God’s household, but he is not a father. David represents the culmination of all God’s plans of creation, the King Messiah who will fulfill the age-old potential that was dashed with Adam’s failure, but David is not a father. Even Noah, literally the father of humanity, is not called the father of the Jewish People. Fatherhood, in the sense that the Patriarchs are fathers, is not measured in biological terms. All that a person is stems from his parents; whatever he becomes represents the development of the latent potential with which he was born. All that Israel is and will yet become, represents the development of the national character that is the legacy of the Patriarchs.

With Abraham, there began a new birth of the history of mankind. Abraham, in a real sense, was as much the ‘first man’ as were Adam and Noah. The Era of Desolation ended with the year 2000. It was indeed a bleak era in history. The fall of Adam, the murder of Abel, the introduction of idolatry, the failure of the first ten generations, the deluge, the failure of then generations after Noah, the Dispersion. But in the year 1948 Abraham was born. When he was fifty-two years old – the year 2000 – he began gathering people together in Charan and teaching them to serve Hashem. With that, an era began. Desolation was over and a new light began to shine upon humanity, the light of Abraham who embodied the light of Torah.

Abraham was a new phenomenon; there had never been anyone like him and he was completely apart from his birthplace and family, even from his parents.

The Midrash (Bereishis Rabbah 39) relates that when God commanded Abraham to leave Charan and begin a new life in Eretz Yisrael, he feared that by deserting his parents, he would cause a desecration of God’s Name, for people would say, ‘He abandoned his father to old age!’

  • The Holy One, Blessed be He, said to Abraham, I absolve you from the obligation to honor your father and mother, but others will not be similarly absolved. What is more, I will relate the story of his death (in the Torah) prior to your leave-taking as it says first, And Terach died in Charan (11:32) and only afterward And Hasham said to Abram ‘Go…from your land’ (12:1).

Maharal explains that Abraham could be absolved from the commandment as was none other, because he was an entirely new and unique entity. In essence, he bore no relationship to Terach because he was the beginning of a new sort of existence on earth. Before him there was desolation and darkness; with him there was Torah and light.

The new birth represented by Abraham was not completed until all three Patriarchs made their combined contribution. That Abraham’s work was insufficient is demonstrated by the fact that he begot an Ishmael; that Isaac went further but did not complete the task his father began is demonstrated by Esau. But of Jacob the sages say, his bed is perfect. Every child of Jacob was a great person in his own right; together they formed the nation, the Tribes of God.

II.  Three Attributes

The three Patriarchs were different, and therein lay their greatness. Isaac and Jacob did not follow Abraham’s well-trodden path to attain their own closeness to God. Each found his own way. In their three ways are the sum total of all possible variations of service to God. Therefore, they are the Fathers: whatever we do was foreshadowed by them; each succeeding generation of Israel with all its great individuals and differing paths to Torah, prayer, kindness and fulfillment of the commandments, is but further growth of their seeds. We are their children.

Each Patriarch had a prime characteristic: Abraham represents the attribute of kindness, grace and compassion; Isaac represents strength or fear; Jacob represents splendor or truth. Let us examine these characteristics, attempt to define them, and see how they manifest themselves in the service of God.

The attribute of the ‘chesed person’ meaning kindness, is the feeling of a person that he must seek to define the needs of other people and fill them. This is an outer-directed trait. The ‘chesed-person’ (pronounced ‘ha said’) acts not out of selfishness nor pity, but out of a genuine desire to help others materially or spiritually, as the case may be.

The attribute of the “gevurah person’ meaning strength, is driven by a fear of transgression and has a powerful drive toward self-perfection. The ‘gevurah person’ (pronounced ja vur rah) examines his deeds and desires, and will tend to refrain from any act that may fall short of the high standards he seeks to attain.

The attribute of the ‘tiferes person) meaning truth seeks to combine chesed and ‘gevurah’, kindness and strength. By exercising a passion for truth, the tiferes-person (pronounced tie fer-ez) finds the middle course between indulgent kindness which can lead to undesirable excess, and self-critical strength which can stifle achievement. By a passion for truth, the tiferes-person combines both extremes into the blend which results in the fulfillment of duty to oneself as well as to others.

The three traits of kindness, fear, and truth are all desirable and, although every person will have them all in varying degrees, each individual will have a character trait that is dominant, one that best expresses his own personality.

Each individual is required also to serve God in accordance with his unique mission by utilizing all the skills, talent, and resources with which he had been endowed by the Creator, for all of them are the tools given him to make possible the performance of his assigned task.

III. Danger and Development

For someone to realize his potential, he must know his own strengths and weaknesses, and understand whether he is primarily motivated by chessed, gevurah, or tiferes. He must recognize the possibilities and dangers of each course, then seek to maximize the former and minimize the latter. And he must create with himself a combination of all three.

Spiritual growth involves the tension of conflicting forces. The chessed-person, by definition, is giving and is humble – not bringing attention to oneself. His goal is to satisfy the need of another. But by giving he receives as well, both in terms of the personal satisfaction and sense of accomplishment, and in terms of the spiritual growth brought on by his generosity. Thus, the recipient earns the gratitude of the giver, for having made possible the act of chesed.

The giver and the receiver fulfill one another. Whether in the have and have-not, the strongest basis of unified, harmonious living is the ability and wish to share with others – and to become enriched through sharing. This brings in its train a growing and intensifying awareness that people are different and that they complement one another; that no individual is perfect, but that the community, by combining diverse outlooks and capabilities into a single unit, can approach a degree of perfection that is beyond the capacity of any of its individual components.

But man can give only what he has. The man with an abundance of Torah knowledge and spiritual insight but a lack of funds cannot fulfill his responsibility of chesed by freely dispensing nickels and pennies while refusing to share his knowledge. In the same respect, the man rich in worldly goods but poor in Torah cannot carry out his obligations by freely dispensing advice and criticism but hoarding his wealth. To act in that manner, obviously, is not generous but deceitful; it displays a zeal not to give but to withhold, for it limits the giving to the inconsequential, to that which is of little use to the giver while clearly demonstrating to the recipient, “What you need of me I shall not give you; what is useless to me, you are free to take.’

The chessed-person must give what he possesses. Only by giving what is of value to the giver does he enrich the receiver and, in turn, become enriched by having contributed to the common store of mutual development. However, those who help others only at minimum cost to themselves can hardly be considered chesed-people.

This does not mean that the help must always be gratis. The person who earns his livelihood by exercising a laboriously cultivated skill cannot be expected to forgo his primary means of providing for himself and his family – nor should he. But there are ways to sell a product or charge for a service, and still be a giver. The grocer who earns a good living, but feels a responsibility to serve his customers honestly and faithfully, is giving even while he rings up this sale. The financial advisor who earns far more than his clients, but who conscientiously extends himself to ensure that their capital is invested where it will best serve their needs rather than his, is providing a service despite his own commission. Of course there is often an obligation to help others without thought of person gain, but the chesed-person does not cease to be a giver even while engaged in the pursuit of profit, as long as his first concern is that he give.

Giving, however, is not enough. For his own perfection, the chesed-person must also develop gevurah instincts: he must look inward as well as outward, and to do so is by no means an exercise in selfishness. People are not stagnant; and even their obligation to others dictates that they facilitate personal growth so that they may be better able to help others. To become a bigger person requires a selfish focus upon oneself. What am I lacking? How can I improve? How can I best absorb a Torah outlook until it is part of my emotional as well as intellectual make-up?

The human being who runs both lanes of this race – neglecting neither chesed nor gevurah, looking both outward and inward – is the most faithful servant of God, himself, and the community. But how is one to navigate his personal course in the human turmoil of constant obstacles, opportunities, temptations, triumphs, and failures?

The trait that provides the power and balance is tiferes, the splendor of truth. The possibility of achieving it was given to man in the form of Torah, God’s own wisdom distilled from the world of the loftiest spheres to provide the formula for life on earth.

IV.  Traits of the Patriarchs

As we have seen, Abraham represents chesed, for the decisive factor in Abraham’s personality was the unceasing urge to help others. Isaac represents gevurah, for his prime trait was the introspective, self-critical fear of God that sought constantly to purify his motives and perfect his deeds. Jacob – the weaver of the triple thread that eternally combined chesed and gevurah with truth as embodied in Torah. Not until Jacob’s work was done was Israel’s ‘Fatherhood’ stage complete, for until then, the national future was not secure. Abraham’s chesed and Isaac’s gevurah both contained the seeds of mortal danger, for although each of them had taken his own primary characteristic and nurtured, guided, chiseled, and polished it into a spiritual masterpiece, it was not yet enough. There is a danger in chesed and a danger in gevurah.

The single-minded determination to help others requires one to ignore his personal needs. It requires total humility, for if one’s own status, dignity, and comfort matter, then he will stand ahead of others. Even if his own desire for fulfillment can be achieved only by winning recognition as the unselfish protector of the weak, then his kindness is tarnished by an inherently selfish need to use the deficiencies of others as stepping stones to the attainment of his own ends.

Such are the dangers of uncontrolled chesed. Nevertheless chesed is good. God created the universe in order to provide the conditions that make His own kindness possible. The election of His chosen people waited twenty generations and two thousand years until the advent of the Patriarch who was, is, and shall always remain the epitome of kindness. Let us not fail to recognize, however, that Abraham’s kindness was not unbounded by principle. When God’s will demanded it, he could set aside his personal inclinations. When necessary, he could take up arms against the abductors of Lot and expel Hagar and Ishmael. He was in control of his chesed and not vice-versa, he said yes not because he was too weak to say no; he took his natural inclination toward kindness and utilized it as a God-serving, not a self-serving vehicle. That was the greatness of Abraham.

It is not incidental that the emergence of the Two Thousand Years of Torah began with Abraham’s initiation of Charanite converts to the teachings of the Torah. Abraham utilized every ounce of his chesed for good, but he also harnessed its potential for excess. He took Torah – the ultimate truth – and allowed it to guide him to gevurah when called for.

He had two sons, both of whom were heirs to his chesed teaching. During the embryonic era in Israel’s development when the seeds of the entire national future were being sown, God wanted Isaac to forge a path all his own. Isaac was endowed with the gevurah personality. But Ishmael broke no new spiritual paths. He saw Abraham’s kindness but he failed to perceive the steel which underlay it, the principle which directed it. His challenge, like Abraham’s was to face the test of chesed and arm himself with the strength within kindness, that would result in the splendor of truth that could be developed within kindness to create the human masterpiece of an Abraham. But Ishmael failed. He perverted kindness into indulgence, eventually to found a nation distinguished for lust, so dedicated to the satisfaction of its passion that it is quite ready to kill and plunder in its service.

Isaac controlled his trait just as Abraham had controlled his. But in gevurah, too, there is a danger. The inward-looking person, dedicated to self-perfection can become obsessed with his own needs with the result that other people become inconsequential, even contemptible, in his eyes. If his own development is paramount, then he can come to regard others as his tools, meant to serve him, to be used by him. The gevurah-person must temper his nature with chesed in order to attain perfection.

Isaac had two sons. Jacob was heir to Isaac’s gevurah and Abraham’s chesed. From his youth he was dweller in the tents of Torah. When he departed from Isaac and Rebecca to found his own home, he secluded himself for fourteen years in the Academy where he immersed himself uncompromisingly into the sea of Torah. With his passion for truth, he formed the perfect blend of attributes and became the final Patriarch, father of the family without blemish.

But Esau was different. He inherited his father’s strength without his grandfather’s compassion and without his brother’s quest for truthful splendor. The result was the viciously selfish person who became the embodiment of callousness and disregard for others. Esau was a murderer because he deemed the lives of others to be too insignificant to stand in the way of his desire. Arrogance, cruelty, plunder, murder – all these are characteristics of Esau the strong, Esau the unbridled. Because Jacob was the ultimate in good, Esau was the ultimate in evil – resulting in his eternal war against all that Israel represents down through the ages.

V.  God is Master

The various Name of God did not come into being with the creation of the universe, and certainly they were not coined by human beings. His Names are eternal just as He is eternal. The universe was created so that even in this mixture of good and evil, spiritual and material, people would come to recognize that Hashem is One and that all emanates from Him and functions in accordance with His will. When Abraham came upon the scene, mankind recognized a multiplicity of gods, one for each aspect of the universe – one for light, one for darkness, one for fertility, one for vegetation and so on.

But Abraham recognized the truth – Hashem is the God, there had to be one Master of the universe and it is He alone Who rules it every moment of every day.

Abraham called Hasham, – Master – and no one had ever done so before. There had been righteous people on earth before him, people who had heard the word of God and served Him, but none had so enthroned Hashem as Master of every aspect of existence as had Abraham.

God Himself was indebted to Abraham because, until he proclaimed Him as Master, the purpose of Creation had been frustrated. God created the universe so that man would perceive Him and serve Him despite the distractions of material existence. Until Abraham’s time, the world had spun in a downward spiral of apathy and sin; creation had failed, lost meaning, serviced no purpose. Then Abraham revealed new vistas of recognition that Hashem was everywhere and controlled everything. What is more, he would be father to a nation that would carry on his mission of standing up to skeptics and enemies until the day when all would acknowledge its message and accept its teaching. Of course, Abraham could be called master of mankind because, whether they realized or not, they owed their existence to him. But that was not all. God called him My Master, because he had presented God with a gift that even He in all His infinite power, could not fashion for Himself. For even God cannot guarantee that man’s mind and heart would choose truth over evil, light over darkness, spirit over flesh, love of God over love of pleasure, recognition that the Master is God and not whatever inexorable force happens to find favor in the eyes of any current generation of non-believers.

Thus Abraham was the one who made God ‘Master,’ and because he accomplished what God had awaited vainly for two thousand years, God called him ‘master.’

It was this new dimension of service to God based on all-embracing recognition that made Abraham the successor to Adam as the father of God’s nation. Before Abraham could become the father of Israel, he had to sanctify himself through circumcision. The sequence of chapter 17 makes it clear that the final gift of the Land and the gift of offspring – the nation and its home – were dependent upon circumcision. From the words of the Sages, we see that circumcision was a critical indication of a loyalty to God that transcended the limitations of the flesh – and even the strictness of natural law.

Circumcision teaches that man must rise above nature. The seven days of the week symbolize the rule of nature forces, for the physical world was created in seven days. Milah, circumcision, is performed on the eighth day of a child’s life to symbolize that it represents the goal of rising above nature. Adam was born circumcised for he was a superior being, but he failed to maintain his lofty standing. By succumbing to sin and g

grasping evil, he fell prey to the natural forces that should have been his servants. He was instrumental in creating a barrier between himself and holiness. Having set his sights downward toward earth, he could no longer look to the heavens as he was created to do. The barrier of the spirit which he had erected was mirrored in his body as the symbol of his closeness to God, his circumcision, was covered by a barrier of flesh.

Abraham tore down the barriers. He saw God everywhere, miracles were natural for him, natural abstractions withered away. He placed himself above the rule of the seven days. God recognized this change in his spiritual essence by giving him the commandment of circumcision.

Perhaps it was in recognition of this overriding symbolism that Abraham refrained from circumcising himself before being specifically commanded to do so, unlike other commandments which he fulfilled voluntarily. Because circumcision represented God’s acknowledgment that the barrier caused by Adam’s sin had been removed, Abraham could not perform it without a specific command. Circumcision with the inner portents of the deed would have no more value than removing some flesh from the elbow or shoulder. Only God could testify that Abraham had become worthy of the deed in all its meaning, that he had become father of the nation that would fulfill the failed hope of Adam.

VI.  Fathers of History

The Patriarchs embodied in their words and deeds the entire, still unfolding course of Jewish history. Even more significant, they set down the moral principles and character traits by which Jews would live and be distinguished.

There are prophecies which are dependent upon the merit of the recipient. The Jews who left Egypt should have entered Eretz Yisrael after receiving the Torah and remain in the wilderness for a relatively brief period. They sinned and as a result the nation remained in the desert for forty years and the adult generation which left Egypt was not granted the privilege of entering the Land. Similarly we find Abraham asking how he can be sure that his descendants will inherit the Land (15:8). As some commentators explain, he was afraid that future generations would not be sufficiently righteous to merit fulfillment of the prophecy on their behalf. Jacob, too, feared that his own righteousness was inadequate to earn God’s help in saving him from Esau’s murderous army (32:11).

But a prophecy accompanied by a symbolic act, cannot be repealed. This doctrine is affirmed by Ramban who goes on to show how events of Abraham’s life must be understood as prophetic symbols guaranteeing future blessings for his descendants (12:6). Other commentators follow Ramban’s lead in searching the story of the Patriarchs for clues to the future of their children.

Abraham’s life began in suffering and pursuit as Nimrod sought to silence his teachings, but from the time God plucked him from Ur Kasdim, his life was serene, secure, and productive. Israel, too, lived in distress during the early years of its national history; it was exiled and enslaved to Pharaohs who sought to bring about its destruction. But from the time God redeemed it from Egypt and pronounced to be His first-born son, it prospered and advanced to the zenith of David’s and Solomon’s reigns, to the Temple, and to the universal respect and acclaim that marked the golden years of the First Commonwealth.

Isaac began life basking in the glow of Abraham’s eminence. But human illness and physical suffering began with Isaac as he became blind in his later years. The eminence of the Abrahamitic family, too declined in Isaac’s time as four hundred years of exile began with the birth of Isaac who was not accorded the reverence shown Abraham (see commentary to 15:13). The middle period of Israel’s history followed the pattern of Isaac’s life: it began with the glory of previous greatness, but it declined in strife and subjugation as nations conquered Eretz Yisrael, extinguished the nation’s ‘light’ – the Holy Temple – and exiled the people.

Jacob, the last Patriarch, embodied the final chapters of Israel’s history. Nearly all of his life was a succession of tribulation and anguish until the last years of his life when he enjoyed peace and serenity in Egypt, his family restored and flourishing as it built toward the future redemption and the gift of Sinai. As the Talmud expounds in Ta’anis 5a, Jacob never died; only his physical shell was removed and interred, but the essential Jacob endures in the highest form of spiritual life. So, too, Israel. Beset by exile and being violently demolished, driven from continent to continent, reviled by foe and pseudo-friend, the nation suffers throughout its life. But the End of Days will bring fulfillment and vindication. The Temple – the eternal Temple – will stand and Israel will be reunited in a spiritual summit that will be vindication of all that has gone before, from which the rays of Torah will light the world, toward which mankind will stream to do His will with a complete and sincere heart.

Noah and Abraham

There were ten generations from Adam to Noah to show how long-suffering God is, since all these generations antagonized Him until He brought the waters of the Flood upon them.

There were ten generations from Noah to Abraham to show how long-suffering He is, since all these generations antagonized Him until our Father Abraham came and took the merit of them all.  (Avon 5:2-3).

I.   Tzaddik – Righteous

Three Words – There are three words formed from the same root, expressing the same concept.  Tzaddik is a righteous person; tzedek is justice in a court of law; tzedakah is ‘charity’.  Three words.  In common expression and understanding they are taken as three widely varying ideals: People think of a tzaddik as a ‘righteous person’ who engages in religious ritual.  Tzedakah, charity and benevolence based on the circumstances of one in need, is far removed from tzedek the strict and scrupulous application of principals of law without regard to the need or circumstances of the accused.

But the Hebrew language teaches us otherwise.  All three words are derived from the word in Hebrew for ‘justice’.  All three concepts are different expressions of the same theme: that God has created the world with a plan and that every human being must see himself as an executor of that plan.  Whether in his personal life, his legal dealings, or his disbursements to the needy, a Jew must see himself as an administrator of justice, apportioning his emotions, time, wisdom, and resources according to the wishes of their ultimate Owner.

Leviticus 19:15 – “Do no wrong in judgment.  Do not favor the poor, and show no honor to the great; with justice shall you judge your neighbor.”

     The verse concludes with the positive command that complements and summarizes the three negative commands with which it begins.  In order to do ‘justice’ properly, the judge must see every person standing before him, rich or poor, as his neighbor, entitled to the same rights and privileges, subject to the same obligations and duties as he is himself.  His judgments are not handed down from on high; they are simply expressions of fairness and right as defined by the Torah (Hirsch).

Deuteronomy 24:13 – “You must return the security to him … that he may bless you, and it shall be for you as a righteous duty (tzedakah) before Hashem, your God.”

Form of Justice – As soon as you perceive that what you are doing is only your duty, your vocation, your task as a human being and as a Jew … (you will) act with no other purpose than to fulfill the will of your Father in Heaven, and to give light and warmth and nourishment just as a ray of sunlight gives light in the service of God.  Why should God give you more than you need unless He intended to make you the administrator of the blessing for the benefit of others, the treasurer of his treasures?  Every penny you can spare is not yours, but should become a tool for bringing blessing to others … That is why our Sages prefer to give the beautiful name of Tzedakah to this act of charity by means of material goods.  For tzedakah is the justice which gives to every creature that which God allots to it. (Horeb).

Tzaddik as Judge – A tzaddik, too, is one who exercises justice.  He knows that he is but the treasurer, not the owner, of the entire store of human and material resources.  The marching orders of his life are contained in the Torah.  For him to do otherwise than to carry them out meticulously would be a lack of justice that is comparable to robbery?  For, indeed, if he were to make use of the breath of life, the spark of intelligence, the potential of wealth in ways opposed to the will of God, is he not misappropriating them from the Owner who has entrusted him with their management?

Man is created with his treasury of potential and, as life goes on, it is filled or depleted.  What he is to have has been decided before his birth; what he does with it is left to him.  Each individual human being is born with a mission all his own.  The child born with the mission of being the teacher of the generation is endowed with the brilliance of intellect, memory, and analytical powers to do so.  The one who is expected to become a supporter of Torah and the poor will be given great wealth.  The mental and material treasures of a human being are the tools he is given to accomplish the goal God set for him, and the tools, can be used well, or they can be wasted.  Money can find its way to worthy causes or it can be invested in a  quest for more wealth; or it can be squandered at roulette wheels.  Man will be called to account for how wisely and righteously he has utilized the gifts placed in his trust.  But one thing must be clear: whatever he needs for his mission will be provided him (Michtav MeEliyahu).

II.  Noah

Genesis 6:9 – “Noah was a righteous man; he was perfect in his generation.”

Perfect Tzaddik – The Torah testifies that Noah was totally righteous, a tzaddik.  By definition he was a man whose life was an unending pattern of justice.  Like the righteous judge who apportions fairly between the claims of those who appear before him, Noah dealt with the conflicting claims that make up every human life, and apportioned his time and patience, his wisdom and knowledge, his wealth and property between himself, his family, and his neighbors.   God’s testimony to Noah’s righteousness is the most eloquent of statements; an unimpeachable guarantee that his every act was measured and considered – and just.

Yet we find declarations about Noah that seem to contradict the lofty characterization of him as a tzaddik.  The Midrash says that Noah was saved from the Flood only because he found grace in the eyes of God – but not because he was deserving!  Noah himself is quoted in the Midrash as saying to God, ‘And as for me, what they have done, I have done equally; what is the difference between me and them?’

What was the sin of the generation that caused the verdict against them to be sealed?  Robbery.  Yet Noah declared himself guilty of their sin, and the Midrash states that his salvation was nothing but an act of mercy because he found grace in God’s eyes.  How are we to understand that ‘righteous’ Noah, the tzaddik who apportioned every aspect of his existence to the proper service of God could be considered on a par with the corrupt?  How can we associate the sin of robbery with Noah?

Zohar says that Noah sinned in not having chastised his fellow men.  Therefore, the destructive, murderous waters of the Flood are called ‘the waters of Noah’ (Isaiah 54:9) – the waters were his responsibility because, had he fulfilled his responsibility fully, the waters might never have come.  Had he chastised and taught, done more than set a towering personal example of righteousness, then mankind might have listened and heeded and survived.  And the mission of Adam might not have ended in torrential failure.

Withholding Speech – Yes, righteous Noah indeed fulfilled his minimum obligations without flaw.  His ‘justice’ could not be faulted.  But he could have done more, and great people can be dealt with as severely for not doing right as for doing wrong.  He was guilty of withholding speech at a time when it could be beneficial to others.  To live amid sin and to have the opportunity to help eradicate it by speaking up, be reasoning, by chastising, by teaching, by pleading – and not to do so, is equally guilty.

What is more, to withhold speech where it is needed is itself considered robbery.  When Sarah accused Abraham of not supporting her against arrogant, rebellious Hagar, she said, ‘my wrong is upon you’ (Genesis 16:5).  Rashi explains that Abraham was to blame for Sarah’s humiliation because he refrained from reprimanding Hagar.  Noah was guilty of ‘robbery’ because he refrained from doing more than the strict dictates of righteousness required him to.

III.  Noah and Abraham

The Difficulty – The verse says that Noah was a righteous man in his generation.  Some of our Sages explain this in praise of Noah: if he was righteous in an evil generation, imagine how much greater he would have been in a time of righteous people.  Other Sages interpret it as an indirect criticism: he was considered righteous in his generation compared to the corruption surrounding him.  Had he lived in Abraham’s time, he would have been insignificant (Rashi; Genesis 6:9).  How are we to understand and resolve these differing views of Noah?

Heavenly scales weigh differently than do ours.  Righteousness in God’s eyes is measured by how well one judges in the universe of his own being.  In the heavenly scale, the great scholar who uses half of his mind’s potential is honored but slightly for the great knowledge gained by using half his capacity; he is dealt with harshly for not having done twice as much.  On the other hand, the laborer whose free moments are spent struggling over a chapter of Mishnah to the limits of his mental capacity, may rightly earn immense reward.  The Holy One, blessed be He, does not count the pages, but the hours.

Noah survived the destruction caused by the failure of the first ten generations, but Abraham did much more: he was so great that he earned for himself all the reward that should have been the lot of the ten generations that preceded him.  Abraham succeeded where all others failed, but how did he become more righteous than Noah?  If we properly understood the term tzaddik as referring to a person who attains the standard set for him by God, then the same pedestal should have borne both Noah and Abraham.

Abram Outgrows His Mission –  Abraham was born Abram (11:26).  His destiny was to be the moral leader of the nation of Aram.  Had he fulfilled that mission and nothing more, he would have been ‘righteous’.  But he did more.  A human has the capacity to rise above his mission.  Through dedication, prayer, love of God – all the attributes of the greatest figures – it is possible for a person to fulfill the mission set forth for him and be granted a new, higher one – just as it is possible for someone to fail so utterly that it becomes impossible for him ever to attain the good for which he was created.

Abram’s name was changed to Abraham because as the Torah says, “I have made you the (moral) father of a multitude of nations (Genesis 17:5).  As Rashi explains, he had outgrown his mission.  No longer was he the ‘Father’ merely of Aram, henceforth he was to become the ‘father’ of all mankind setting a moral standard that would become the goal of the next four millenia of human history and that would bring the Glory of God to earth on Mount Sinai, in the parchment and letters of the Torah, and finally, in the very being of his descendants.  This aspect of Abraham’s greatness overshadowed Noah’s.  Noah fulfilled his mission – he even attempted to rebuke his generations. But Abraham rose above his mission and thereby gained a new one.  Because he sanctified God’s Name far above the extent for which he was created, he earned the merit which would have belonged to all the others had they done what they were created to.

Noah faulted himself for not having done more.  He could have.  Abraham did. That a ‘perfect tzaddik’ is taken to account for not having done much more than he should have been expected to, is in itself an eloquent tribute to his greatness.

Ten Generations – The number ‘ten’ in Scriptures or the Oral Torah, is a reference to the Ten Heavenly Emanations by means of which God’s Presence descends from heaven and makes itself manifest.  Thus we have the ten statements with which God created heaven and earth; Ten Commandments; the ten tests of Abraham; and the ten plagues upon Egypt.  All of these phenomena were aspects of revelation.  Through each, man and the universe were elevated to new perceptions of God’s holiness and presence.

Of the same order were the ten generations from Adam to Noah and the ten from Noah to Abraham.  The number ten was not coincidental; God had a plan of development which was to proceed and develop until it reached its spiritual culmination in ten generations.  The master plan of creation was Torah and it was to enable man to perfect himself through the study of Torah and the performance of its commands that heaven and earth were created.  The divine intention was that God’s Presence be revealed behind the obscurity of earth’s hiddenness through Adam, and that man’s perception of it grow and intensify stage by stage, emanation by emanation, until the tenth generation when it was to reach its climax.  Then, the Torah would be given and all mankind would achieve God’s final purpose and become ‘a kingdom of priests and a holy nation’ (Exodus 19:6).

     The process was to begin again from righteous Noah who signaled a new and better beginning by bringing offerings of thanksgiving and dedication to God after the deluge.  Once again, God set in motion the chain of development that was to culminate in man’s perfection and the giving of the Torah.  Again, man did not rise to the challenge.  The ten generations sinned increasingly, angering God more and more, even attempting to challenge His mastery of the earth and do battle with Him by erecting their Tower of Babel (Genesis 11:1-9).  But this chain of ten had a different ending than the earlier one.  Had it ended in total failure, then no one can know what sort of misfortune might have been visited upon man.  Instead it ended with Abraham.  By his own greatness, a greatness he proved by elevating himself through a succession of ten tests, he achieved in his person what all ten generations had failed to do.

Until Abraham – ‘Abraham performed the commandments of the Torah before they were given’ (Yoma 28b).  He reached so high a level that his own words and thoughts became Torah; he united himself with the mind of God until his own thoughts and wisdom became identical with God’s.  Thus, in a more symbolic sense, the Divine Plan was fulfilled and Torah was ‘given’ – not to the flawed generation of Babel – it was dispersed; not by giving the Tablets and the Torah in its present form – that was left for Moses and the children of Israel.  But the Torah was given and nurtured in Abraham who, in a real sense, began a new history of the world.

IV.  Crucial Moments

     The Sixth Century – The Divine Plan has decreed that there be times when particular manifestations of holiness are visited upon earth.  Genesis 7:11 “In the six hundredth year of the life of Noah…all the fountains of the great deep and the windows of the heavens were opened.” Zohar comments that the ‘wellsprings of the deep’ refers to the wisdom from below, man’s capability through the Oral Torah to broaden and develop the wisdom of Torah.  The ‘windows of heaven’ refers to the Written Torah, God’s gift from heaven.  From the moment of creation, that year was foreordained to be a time of awesome Godly manifestations.  Had man been worthy, he would have received the Written and Oral Torahs and been worthy of broadening and deepening it through the Oral Torah.

The six hundredth year of Noah’s life was chosen as a year when a flood of wisdom would descend upon earth.  But like all heavenly gifts, man is free to decide how he will use it or whether he will be worthy to receive it.

The generation of Noah should have been beneficiary of this ‘water’ – water as an allegorical reference to Torah.  But they were unworthy.  So unworthy were they that ‘water’ – which in God’s spiritual world refers to wisdom – became the water of the Flood that blotted out man.

The generation of the Dispersion, too, was destined for a blossoming of knowledge.  The gift of Torah was ready for them, but instead they became the subordinates of Nimrod.  They had all the prerequisites of greatness, but they abused them and so, lost the opportunity to become the fulfillment of God’s plan.

A New Potential – But there was one man among them who was not swept along by the tide.  He was forty-eight years old and he knew that his master was Hashem, not Nimrod.  Because he persevered, the blessing of Torah that was destined for his countrymen concentrated upon him.  He recognized at the age of three that there had to be a single God Who created and ruled the universe.  Now, at forty-eight, he experienced a new revelation of Godly wisdom – of Torah – in the year and the place destined for revelation – and recognized his Creator as he never had before.  His name was Abram and the Sages say, at the age of forty-eight, Abram recognized his Creator (Midrash).

Unlearned Lessons – In Babel, Abram recognized his Maker and Nimrod recognized his own sword and bow.  Noah was still alive as were his three sons – four people noble, righteous patriarch of the human race.  Surely Noah cried out against the lunacy of building the pointless tower in an insane effort to ascend to heaven and compete with God.  Surely he told his great grandchildren that a merciful God could turn wrathful in the face of such iniquity.  And Abram who would spend a lifetime of kindness in drawing people close to God’s service was unafraid of Nimrod and his threats of death; Abram, too, surely protested.  But the people didn’t listen.

Noah was perfect and righteous.  He could save his family, but not the world.  Abram, too, was perfect and righteous and he salvaged the sparks of holiness from the madness of Babel.  But then he added a new dimension to his mission by becoming Abraham, leader of all the world.  He was so great that he acquired all the merit that had been trodden underfoot by his own generation and all those before.  In so doing, he realized and fulfilled the purpose of creation and earned for his children the most treasured gift that God could bestow on any of his creatures – The Torah.

V.  The Ark

The Robber:  The Flood was precipitated by robbery.  God can endure patiently all varieties of sin, waiting for repentance, exacting punishment, building for better times in the future.  But robbery represents an unpardonable low in human behavior because it shows man as a selfish being concerned with himself alone even at the expense of others.

God tolerated Israel’s most grievous sins as long as they were loyal to and considerate of one another.  The present exile, the Exile of Edom, was brought about by Rome which, the Sages teach, was descended from Esau.  His dominant characteristic was violence and murder.  That, too, is akin to robbery. The murderer will allow nothing to stand in his way.  And if the life of another human being bars the achievement of his goal – he will shed blood to gain it.  Because Israel in the declining years of the Second Commonwealth sinned in its social life through jealousy, hatred, and failure to extend themselves for the benefit of one another, they were placed under the domination of the nation that exemplified cruel selfishness.

The destruction of the First Temple was caused because Israel sunk into lust.  It was exiled in the hands of Babylonia, a nation that was the leading oriental example of pleasure-seeking self-indulgence.  This exile fit the sin.

The Ark’s Lesson – To save earthly life by means of an ark and miraculous salvation from the ravages of the Flood would hardly have sufficed if the sin that finally caused the Flood had remained totally unredeemed.  Therefore, the ark had to be more than a protection against the raging elements outside it; it had to enclose creatures led and cared for by Noah and his family, forcing them together, imposing upon them an awesome regimen of selflessness that allowed not a free moment for self-indulgence.  Thereby, a human tradition was re-imposed.  Cain asked, ‘Am I my brother’s keeper?’  Noah answered, ‘Yes, I am the keeper of everyone, from human being to gnat, from docile lamb to voracious lion.’

For Noah personally, this was a vital lesson.  He was taken to task for not having shown sufficient concern for his generation, for not rebuking them, praying for them – saving them.  He had been content to protect his own righteousness.  His labors in the ark demonstrated to him that he must feel a responsibility for all others.

Of course, his task could have been eased, but that would have destroyed a vital function of the ark.  For the ark was an incubator of goodness.  A necessary ingredient of the salvation was God’s command that the conditions for future survival be developed in the ark.  So Noah and his family became caretakers for all surviving animal life, laboring, trudging, serving, so that when the ancestors of humanity emerged from the ark to rebuild the deluged remains of the earth, they would do it with a reborn awareness of the role of man as a caring, unselfish being (Harav Gifter).

VI.  Shem and Japheth

Greece and Israel – The characteristics of Shem and Japheth were different, but they were intended to be complementary.  Japheth was blessed with beauty and sensitivity; Shem with holiness and the Divine Presence.  Of the many nations descending from both, the blessing of Japheth took root in Greece, while the blessing of Shem rested on Israel.

Noah’s blessing (9:27) –  “May God extend the boundaries of Japheth, but he will dwell in the tents of Shem”.  The Talmud teaches: “the beauty of Japheth (the Greek language, the most beautiful of tongues should be in the tents of Shem.” (Megillah 9b)  This interpretation of Noah’s blessing was used by the Sages to permit the translation of the Five Books of Moses into Greek.

Japheth’s Role – Noah used the name ‘Elokim’ in giving his blessing to Japheth.  It is the name of God that represents His dominance over nature for, as the commentators note, has the same numerical value, 86, as the law of nature.  Noah bestowed upon Japheth the blessings of nature, the ability to perceive and create beauty in this world, but he told his open, expressive, perceptive, gifted son that his achievements must ‘dwell in the tents of Shem.’  Otherwise, his gifts would be worse than wasted; they would become a destructive, corrupting force,  Beauty can elevate man and it can corrode him.  It can inspire man and it can degrade him.  For man is more susceptible to his heart and his senses than to his mind and his soul.

The Conflict – The beauty of Japheth and the tents of Shem reached their time of coming together during the period of the Second Temple.  It was begun upon the command of Cyrus, a descendant of Japheth.  His motives were pure at first, but later his respect for God and love for the Jews changed to wickedness (Rosh Hashanah 4a-b).  Had his motives remained pure, the Second Temple might have achieved the holiness and Divine Presence of the First, but because he fell from his grandeur, the Temple that originated with his benevolence could not become worthy of so lofty a stature (Yoma 9b-10a).

Then came the reign of Antiochus and the Syrian-Greeks.  The Syrians, bearers of the blessing of Japheth, imposed their culture upon Israel and attempted to destroy its allegiance to the God Who dwelt in the tents of Shem.  They defiled the Temple and chose three commandments as their prime targets:

The Sabbath: If God was the eternal Creator and continuous resuscitator of the universe and if His Torah formed the blueprint and formula for the existence and purpose of Creation, then Greek culture would have to stand aside and bow humbly before the tents of Shem.  This, Antiochus could not tolerate.

The New Moon:  the symbol of man’s obligation to instill holiness in time.  Time is meaningless until the Sanhedrin hallows it by proclaiming ‘the new moon is sanctified, it is sanctified!’, and when this is done, the festivals – the appointed meeting places in time between God and man – enter the calendar and raise it from a record of material pursuit and struggle to a vehicle of holiness.  Antiochus and his culture were not absolute; they were either servants of holiness or crude intrusions upon the human purpose.

Circumcision: the declaration that the physical and the spiritual must be intertwined.  The physical world is not separate from and independent of the spiritual.  The body must bear the mark of allegiance to God’s covenant, the restraining mark which tell it, ‘You are a servant not a master; you are host to a soul and you must elevate yourself to its exalted level.’  Beauty and pleasure were not the independent virtues Antiochus said they were.  They were confined by Torah or they were nothing.

A world without a Creator, a calendar without holiness, a body without restraint – these were the goals of a culture that had accepted the gifts but not the goals of Noah’s blessing to Japheth.  External grace and splendor covering a corrosive emptiness.  To this had the beauty of Japheth been brought.

Greece should have placed its culture at the service of Shem, used it to help provide a glorious dwelling place for the Divine Presence.  Instead it’s splendor became darkness.

Noah and Abraham

There were ten generations from Adam to Noah to show how long-suffering God is, since all these generations antagonized Him until He brought the waters of the Flood upon them.

There were ten generations from Noah to Abraham to show how long-suffering He is, since all these generations antagonized Him until our Father Abraham came and took the merit of them all.  (Avon 5:2-3).

  1.  Tzaddik – Righteous

Three Words – There are three words formed from the same root, expressing the same concept.  Tzaddik is a righteous person; tzedek is justice in a court of law; tzedakah is ‘charity’.  Three words.  In common expression and understanding they are taken as three widely varying ideals: People think of a tzaddik as a ‘righteous person’ who engages in religious ritual.  Tzedakah, charity and benevolence based on the circumstances of one in need, is far removed from tzedek the strict and scrupulous application of principals of law without regard to the need or circumstances of the accused.

But the Hebrew language teaches us otherwise.  All three words are derived from the word in Hebrew for ‘justice’.  All three concepts are different expressions of the same theme: that God has created the world with a plan and that every human being must see himself as an executor of that plan.  Whether in his personal life, his legal dealings, or his disbursements to the needy, a Jew must see himself as an administrator of justice, apportioning his emotions, time, wisdom, and resources according to the wishes of their ultimate Owner.

Leviticus 19:15 – “Do no wrong in judgment.  Do not favor the poor, and show no honor to the great; with justice shall you judge your neighbor.”

     The verse concludes with the positive command that complements and summarizes the three negative commands with which it begins.  In order to do ‘justice’ properly, the judge must see every person standing before him, rich or poor, as his neighbor, entitled to the same rights and privileges, subject to the same obligations and duties as he is himself.  His judgments are not handed down from on high; they are simply expressions of fairness and right as defined by the Torah (Hirsch).

Deuteronomy 24:13 – “You must return the security to him … that he may bless you, and it shall be for you as a righteous duty (tzedakah) before Hashem, your God.”

Form of Justice – As soon as you perceive that what you are doing is only your duty, your vocation, your task as a human being and as a Jew … (you will) act with no other purpose than to fulfill the will of your Father in Heaven, and to give light and warmth and nourishment just as a ray of sunlight gives light in the service of God.  Why should God give you more than you need unless He intended to make you the administrator of the blessing for the benefit of others, the treasurer of his treasures?  Every penny you can spare is not yours, but should become a tool for bringing blessing to others … That is why our Sages prefer to give the beautiful name of Tzedakah to this act of charity by means of material goods.  For tzedakah is the justice which gives to every creature that which God allots to it. (Horeb).

Tzaddik as Judge – A tzaddik, too, is one who exercises justice.  He knows that he is but the treasurer, not the owner, of the entire store of human and material resources.  The marching orders of his life are contained in the Torah.  For him to do otherwise than to carry them out meticulously would be a lack of justice that is comparable to robbery?  For, indeed, if he were to make use of the breath of life, the spark of intelligence, the potential of wealth in ways opposed to the will of God, is he not misappropriating them from the Owner who has entrusted him with their management?

Man is created with his treasury of potential and, as life goes on, it is filled or depleted.  What he is to have has been decided before his birth; what he does with it is left to him.  Each individual human being is born with a mission all his own.  The child born with the mission of being the teacher of the generation is endowed with the brilliance of intellect, memory, and analytical powers to do so.  The one who is expected to become a supporter of Torah and the poor will be given great wealth.  The mental and material treasures of a human being are the tools he is given to accomplish the goal God set for him, and the tools, can be used well, or they can be wasted.  Money can find its way to worthy causes or it can be invested in a  quest for more wealth; or it can be squandered at roulette wheels.  Man will be called to account for how wisely and righteously he has utilized the gifts placed in his trust.  But one thing must be clear: whatever he needs for his mission will be provided him (Michtav MeEliyahu).

  1.  Noah

Genesis 6:9 – “Noah was a righteous man; he was perfect in his generation.”

Perfect Tzaddik – The Torah testifies that Noah was totally righteous, a tzaddik.  By definition he was a man whose life was an unending pattern of justice.  Like the righteous judge who apportions fairly between the claims of those who appear before him, Noah dealt with the conflicting claims that make up every human life, and apportioned his time and patience, his wisdom and knowledge, his wealth and property between himself, his family, and his neighbors.   God’s testimony to Noah’s righteousness is the most eloquent of statements; an unimpeachable guarantee that his every act was measured and considered – and just.

Yet we find declarations about Noah that seem to contradict the lofty characterization of him as a tzaddik.  The Midrash says that Noah was saved from the Flood only because he found grace in the eyes of God – but not because he was deserving!  Noah himself is quoted in the Midrash as saying to God, ‘And as for me, what they have done, I have done equally; what is the difference between me and them?’

What was the sin of the generation that caused the verdict against them to be sealed?  Robbery.  Yet Noah declared himself guilty of their sin, and the Midrash states that his salvation was nothing but an act of mercy because he found grace in God’s eyes.  How are we to understand that ‘righteous’ Noah, the tzaddik who apportioned every aspect of his existence to the proper service of God could be considered on a par with the corrupt?  How can we associate the sin of robbery with Noah?

Zohar says that Noah sinned in not having chastised his fellow men.  Therefore, the destructive, murderous waters of the Flood are called ‘the waters of Noah’ (Isaiah 54:9) – the waters were his responsibility because, had he fulfilled his responsibility fully, the waters might never have come.  Had he chastised and taught, done more than set a towering personal example of righteousness, then mankind might have listened and heeded and survived.  And the mission of Adam might not have ended in torrential failure.

Withholding Speech – Yes, righteous Noah indeed fulfilled his minimum obligations without flaw.  His ‘justice’ could not be faulted.  But he could have done more, and great people can be dealt with as severely for not doing right as for doing wrong.  He was guilty of withholding speech at a time when it could be beneficial to others.  To live amid sin and to have the opportunity to help eradicate it by speaking up, be reasoning, by chastising, by teaching, by pleading – and not to do so, is equally guilty.

What is more, to withhold speech where it is needed is itself considered robbery.  When Sarah accused Abraham of not supporting her against arrogant, rebellious Hagar, she said, ‘my wrong is upon you’ (Genesis 16:5).  Rashi explains that Abraham was to blame for Sarah’s humiliation because he refrained from reprimanding Hagar.  Noah was guilty of ‘robbery’ because he refrained from doing more than the strict dictates of righteousness required him to.

III.  Noah and Abraham

The Difficulty – The verse says that Noah was a righteous man in his generation.  Some of our Sages explain this in praise of Noah: if he was righteous in an evil generation, imagine how much greater he would have been in a time of righteous people.  Other Sages interpret it as an indirect criticism: he was considered righteous in his generation compared to the corruption surrounding him.  Had he lived in Abraham’s time, he would have been insignificant (Rashi; Genesis 6:9).  How are we to understand and resolve these differing views of Noah?

Heavenly scales weigh differently than do ours.  Righteousness in God’s eyes is measured by how well one judges in the universe of his own being.  In the heavenly scale, the great scholar who uses half of his mind’s potential is honored but slightly for the great knowledge gained by using half his capacity; he is dealt with harshly for not having done twice as much.  On the other hand, the laborer whose free moments are spent struggling over a chapter of Mishnah to the limits of his mental capacity, may rightly earn immense reward.  The Holy One, blessed be He, does not count the pages, but the hours.

Noah survived the destruction caused by the failure of the first ten generations, but Abraham did much more: he was so great that he earned for himself all the reward that should have been the lot of the ten generations that preceded him.  Abraham succeeded where all others failed, but how did he become more righteous than Noah?  If we properly understood the term tzaddik as referring to a person who attains the standard set for him by God, then the same pedestal should have borne both Noah and Abraham.

Abram Outgrows His Mission –  Abraham was born Abram (11:26).  His destiny was to be the moral leader of the nation of Aram.  Had he fulfilled that mission and nothing more, he would have been ‘righteous’.  But he did more.  A human has the capacity to rise above his mission.  Through dedication, prayer, love of God – all the attributes of the greatest figures – it is possible for a person to fulfill the mission set forth for him and be granted a new, higher one – just as it is possible for someone to fail so utterly that it becomes impossible for him ever to attain the good for which he was created.

Abram’s name was changed to Abraham because as the Torah says, “I have made you the (moral) father of a multitude of nations (Genesis 17:5).  As Rashi explains, he had outgrown his mission.  No longer was he the ‘Father’ merely of Aram, henceforth he was to become the ‘father’ of all mankind setting a moral standard that would become the goal of the next four millenia of human history and that would bring the Glory of God to earth on Mount Sinai, in the parchment and letters of the Torah, and finally, in the very being of his descendants.  This aspect of Abraham’s greatness overshadowed Noah’s.  Noah fulfilled his mission – he even attempted to rebuke his generations. But Abraham rose above his mission and thereby gained a new one.  Because he sanctified God’s Name far above the extent for which he was created, he earned the merit which would have belonged to all the others had they done what they were created to.

Noah faulted himself for not having done more.  He could have.  Abraham did. That a ‘perfect tzaddik’ is taken to account for not having done much more than he should have been expected to, is in itself an eloquent tribute to his greatness.

Ten Generations – The number ‘ten’ in Scriptures or the Oral Torah, is a reference to the Ten Heavenly Emanations by means of which God’s Presence descends from heaven and makes itself manifest.  Thus we have the ten statements with which God created heaven and earth; Ten Commandments; the ten tests of Abraham; and the ten plagues upon Egypt.  All of these phenomena were aspects of revelation.  Through each, man and the universe were elevated to new perceptions of God’s holiness and presence.

Of the same order were the ten generations from Adam to Noah and the ten from Noah to Abraham.  The number ten was not coincidental; God had a plan of development which was to proceed and develop until it reached its spiritual culmination in ten generations.  The master plan of creation was Torah and it was to enable man to perfect himself through the study of Torah and the performance of its commands that heaven and earth were created.  The divine intention was that God’s Presence be revealed behind the obscurity of earth’s hiddenness through Adam, and that man’s perception of it grow and intensify stage by stage, emanation by emanation, until the tenth generation when it was to reach its climax.  Then, the Torah would be given and all mankind would achieve God’s final purpose and become ‘a kingdom of priests and a holy nation’ (Exodus 19:6).

     The process was to begin again from righteous Noah who signaled a new and better beginning by bringing offerings of thanksgiving and dedication to God after the deluge.  Once again, God set in motion the chain of development that was to culminate in man’s perfection and the giving of the Torah.  Again, man did not rise to the challenge.  The ten generations sinned increasingly, angering God more and more, even attempting to challenge His mastery of the earth and do battle with Him by erecting their Tower of Babel (Genesis 11:1-9).  But this chain of ten had a different ending than the earlier one.  Had it ended in total failure, then no one can know what sort of misfortune might have been visited upon man.  Instead it ended with Abraham.  By his own greatness, a greatness he proved by elevating himself through a succession of ten tests, he achieved in his person what all ten generations had failed to do.

Until Abraham – ‘Abraham performed the commandments of the Torah before they were given’ (Yoma 28b).  He reached so high a level that his own words and thoughts became Torah; he united himself with the mind of God until his own thoughts and wisdom became identical with God’s.  Thus, in a more symbolic sense, the Divine Plan was fulfilled and Torah was ‘given’ – not to the flawed generation of Babel – it was dispersed; not by giving the Tablets and the Torah in its present form – that was left for Moses and the children of Israel.  But the Torah was given and nurtured in Abraham who, in a real sense, began a new history of the world.

  1.  Crucial Moments

     The Sixth Century – The Divine Plan has decreed that there be times when particular manifestations of holiness are visited upon earth.  Genesis 7:11 “In the six hundredth year of the life of Noah…all the fountains of the great deep and the windows of the heavens were opened.” Zohar comments that the ‘wellsprings of the deep’ refers to the wisdom from below, man’s capability through the Oral Torah to broaden and develop the wisdom of Torah.  The ‘windows of heaven’ refers to the Written Torah, God’s gift from heaven.  From the moment of creation, that year was foreordained to be a time of awesome Godly manifestations.  Had man been worthy, he would have received the Written and Oral Torahs and been worthy of broadening and deepening it through the Oral Torah.

The six hundredth year of Noah’s life was chosen as a year when a flood of wisdom would descend upon earth.  But like all heavenly gifts, man is free to decide how he will use it or whether he will be worthy to receive it.

The generation of Noah should have been beneficiary of this ‘water’ – water as an allegorical reference to Torah.  But they were unworthy.  So unworthy were they that ‘water’ – which in God’s spiritual world refers to wisdom – became the water of the Flood that blotted out man.

The generation of the Dispersion, too, was destined for a blossoming of knowledge.  The gift of Torah was ready for them, but instead they became the subordinates of Nimrod.  They had all the prerequisites of greatness, but they abused them and so, lost the opportunity to become the fulfillment of God’s plan.

A New Potential – But there was one man among them who was not swept along by the tide.  He was forty-eight years old and he knew that his master was Hashem, not Nimrod.  Because he persevered, the blessing of Torah that was destined for his countrymen concentrated upon him.  He recognized at the age of three that there had to be a single God Who created and ruled the universe.  Now, at forty-eight, he experienced a new revelation of Godly wisdom – of Torah – in the year and the place destined for revelation – and recognized his Creator as he never had before.  His name was Abram and the Sages say, at the age of forty-eight, Abram recognized his Creator (Midrash).

Unlearned Lessons – In Babel, Abram recognized his Maker and Nimrod recognized his own sword and bow.  Noah was still alive as were his three sons – four people noble, righteous patriarch of the human race.  Surely Noah cried out against the lunacy of building the pointless tower in an insane effort to ascend to heaven and compete with God.  Surely he told his great grandchildren that a merciful God could turn wrathful in the face of such iniquity.  And Abram who would spend a lifetime of kindness in drawing people close to God’s service was unafraid of Nimrod and his threats of death; Abram, too, surely protested.  But the people didn’t listen.

Noah was perfect and righteous.  He could save his family, but not the world.  Abram, too, was perfect and righteous and he salvaged the sparks of holiness from the madness of Babel.  But then he added a new dimension to his mission by becoming Abraham, leader of all the world.  He was so great that he acquired all the merit that had been trodden underfoot by his own generation and all those before.  In so doing, he realized and fulfilled the purpose of creation and earned for his children the most treasured gift that God could bestow on any of his creatures – The Torah.

  1.  The Ark

The Robber:  The Flood was precipitated by robbery.  God can endure patiently all varieties of sin, waiting for repentance, exacting punishment, building for better times in the future.  But robbery represents an unpardonable low in human behavior because it shows man as a selfish being concerned with himself alone even at the expense of others.

God tolerated Israel’s most grievous sins as long as they were loyal to and considerate of one another.  The present exile, the Exile of Edom, was brought about by Rome which, the Sages teach, was descended from Esau.  His dominant characteristic was violence and murder.  That, too, is akin to robbery. The murderer will allow nothing to stand in his way.  And if the life of another human being bars the achievement of his goal – he will shed blood to gain it.  Because Israel in the declining years of the Second Commonwealth sinned in its social life through jealousy, hatred, and failure to extend themselves for the benefit of one another, they were placed under the domination of the nation that exemplified cruel selfishness.

The destruction of the First Temple was caused because Israel sunk into lust.  It was exiled in the hands of Babylonia, a nation that was the leading oriental example of pleasure-seeking self-indulgence.  This exile fit the sin.

The Ark’s Lesson – To save earthly life by means of an ark and miraculous salvation from the ravages of the Flood would hardly have sufficed if the sin that finally caused the Flood had remained totally unredeemed.  Therefore, the ark had to be more than a protection against the raging elements outside it; it had to enclose creatures led and cared for by Noah and his family, forcing them together, imposing upon them an awesome regimen of selflessness that allowed not a free moment for self-indulgence.  Thereby, a human tradition was re-imposed.  Cain asked, ‘Am I my brother’s keeper?’  Noah answered, ‘Yes, I am the keeper of everyone, from human being to gnat, from docile lamb to voracious lion.’

For Noah personally, this was a vital lesson.  He was taken to task for not having shown sufficient concern for his generation, for not rebuking them, praying for them – saving them.  He had been content to protect his own righteousness.  His labors in the ark demonstrated to him that he must feel a responsibility for all others.

Of course, his task could have been eased, but that would have destroyed a vital function of the ark.  For the ark was an incubator of goodness.  A necessary ingredient of the salvation was God’s command that the conditions for future survival be developed in the ark.  So Noah and his family became caretakers for all surviving animal life, laboring, trudging, serving, so that when the ancestors of humanity emerged from the ark to rebuild the deluged remains of the earth, they would do it with a reborn awareness of the role of man as a caring, unselfish being (Harav Gifter).

  1.  Shem and Japheth

Greece and Israel – The characteristics of Shem and Japheth were different, but they were intended to be complementary.  Japheth was blessed with beauty and sensitivity; Shem with holiness and the Divine Presence.  Of the many nations descending from both, the blessing of Japheth took root in Greece, while the blessing of Shem rested on Israel.

Noah’s blessing (9:27) –  “May God extend the boundaries of Japheth, but he will dwell in the tents of Shem”.  The Talmud teaches: “the beauty of Japheth (the Greek language, the most beautiful of tongues should be in the tents of Shem.” (Megillah 9b)  This interpretation of Noah’s blessing was used by the Sages to permit the translation of the Five Books of Moses into Greek.

Japheth’s Role – Noah used the name ‘Elokim’ in giving his blessing to Japheth.  It is the name of God that represents His dominance over nature for, as the commentators note, has the same numerical value, 86, as the law of nature.  Noah bestowed upon Japheth the blessings of nature, the ability to perceive and create beauty in this world, but he told his open, expressive, perceptive, gifted son that his achievements must ‘dwell in the tents of Shem.’  Otherwise, his gifts would be worse than wasted; they would become a destructive, corrupting force,  Beauty can elevate man and it can corrode him.  It can inspire man and it can degrade him.  For man is more susceptible to his heart and his senses than to his mind and his soul.

The Conflict – The beauty of Japheth and the tents of Shem reached their time of coming together during the period of the Second Temple.  It was begun upon the command of Cyrus, a descendant of Japheth.  His motives were pure at first, but later his respect for God and love for the Jews changed to wickedness (Rosh Hashanah 4a-b).  Had his motives remained pure, the Second Temple might have achieved the holiness and Divine Presence of the First, but because he fell from his grandeur, the Temple that originated with his benevolence could not become worthy of so lofty a stature (Yoma 9b-10a).

Then came the reign of Antiochus and the Syrian-Greeks.  The Syrians, bearers of the blessing of Japheth, imposed their culture upon Israel and attempted to destroy its allegiance to the God Who dwelt in the tents of Shem.  They defiled the Temple and chose three commandments as their prime targets:

The Sabbath: If God was the eternal Creator and continuous resuscitator of the universe and if His Torah formed the blueprint and formula for the existence and purpose of Creation, then Greek culture would have to stand aside and bow humbly before the tents of Shem.  This, Antiochus could not tolerate.

The New Moon:  the symbol of man’s obligation to instill holiness in time.  Time is meaningless until the Sanhedrin hallows it by proclaiming ‘the new moon is sanctified, it is sanctified!’, and when this is done, the festivals – the appointed meeting places in time between God and man – enter the calendar and raise it from a record of material pursuit and struggle to a vehicle of holiness.  Antiochus and his culture were not absolute; they were either servants of holiness or crude intrusions upon the human purpose.

Circumcision: the declaration that the physical and the spiritual must be intertwined.  The physical world is not separate from and independent of the spiritual.  The body must bear the mark of allegiance to God’s covenant, the restraining mark which tell it, ‘You are a servant not a master; you are host to a soul and you must elevate yourself to its exalted level.’  Beauty and pleasure were not the independent virtues Antiochus said they were.  They were confined by Torah or they were nothing.

A world without a Creator, a calendar without holiness, a body without restraint – these were the goals of a culture that had accepted the gifts but not the goals of Noah’s blessing to Japheth.  External grace and splendor covering a corrosive emptiness.  To this had the beauty of Japheth been brought.

Greece should have placed its culture at the service of Shem, used it to help provide a glorious dwelling place for the Divine Presence.  Instead it’s splendor became darkness.